Question 1
4 marksSource B: From the opening of the Supreme Court's judgment in the school segregation cases, read by Chief Justice Earl Warren on 17 May 1954. The Court had first heard the cases in December 1952 and had then asked the lawyers on both sides to answer further questions, which they argued in December 1953.
These cases come to us from the States of Kansas, South Carolina, Virginia, and Delaware. They are premised on different facts and different local conditions, but a common legal question justifies their consideration together in this consolidated opinion.
In each of the cases, minors of the Negro race, through their legal representatives, seek the aid of the courts in obtaining admission to the public schools of their community on a nonsegregated basis. In each instance, they had been denied admission to schools attended by white children under laws requiring or permitting segregation according to race. ...
The plaintiffs contend that segregated public schools are not "equal" and cannot be made "equal," and that hence they are deprived of the equal protection of the laws. ... Argument was heard in the 1952 Term, and reargument was heard this Term on certain questions propounded by the Court.
Reargument was largely devoted to the circumstances surrounding the adoption of the Fourteenth Amendment in 1868. It covered exhaustively consideration of the Amendment in Congress, ratification by the states, then-existing practices in racial segregation, and the views of proponents and opponents of the Amendment. ...
Source C: From an account written for this course, based on interviews given in later life by former students of Robert R. Moton High School in Prince Edward County, Virginia. The writer is remembering the students' strike of April 1951, which led to one of the cases later combined in the Brown v. Topeka case.
Moton was built for about 180 students, but by 1951 there were more than 450 of us. The county's answer was to put up buildings covered in tar paper. When it rained, the roofs leaked and some of us held umbrellas in class. Our parents had asked the school board for a new school again and again, and they were always told to wait. So on 23 April 1951 we walked out, all of us, and we stayed out for two weeks. It was our idea, not the grown-ups'. We wrote to the NAACP's lawyers, and they said they would help only if we asked for an end to segregated schools, not just a new building. Most of our parents agreed, even though they knew what it might cost them.
Interpretation 1: From Counsel for Equality: The NAACP's Road to Brown, 1930-1954 by Harold Brackley (fictional), published in 1975.
The Brown decision was above all the achievement of the NAACP's lawyers. For twenty years Charles Houston and then Thurgood Marshall followed a careful plan, winning one case after another until the Supreme Court had accepted that separate law schools and graduate schools could not be equal. By 1950 Marshall was ready to attack segregation itself. It was the NAACP's lawyers who prepared the school cases, gathered the evidence of historians and psychologists, and argued them twice before the Supreme Court. Without that legal skill, and the money the NAACP raised to pay for it, no family in Kansas or South Carolina could have taken on a state government and won.
Interpretation 2: From Ordinary Courage: The Families behind Brown v. Board by Delia Fenwright (fictional), published in 2004.
Brown v. Board is often told as the story of brilliant lawyers, but the lawyers could do nothing without people willing to put their names on a lawsuit. In Clarendon County, South Carolina, parents who signed a petition against the segregated schools lost their jobs and their credit. In Prince Edward County, Virginia, sixteen-year-old Barbara Johns led her fellow students out of their overcrowded school in 1951 and only then asked the NAACP for help. In Topeka, thirteen families agreed to try to enrol their children in white schools so that a case could be brought. These ordinary people took the risks. The courage of local communities made Brown possible.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about the role of ordinary Black families in the Brown v. Topeka case (1954). You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B, the Supreme Court's own judgment, presents Brown as a legal argument: the children act 'through their legal representatives', 'The plaintiffs contend' that segregated schools 'cannot be made "equal"', and the reargument 'covered exhaustively' the history of the Fourteenth Amendment. A historian relying on court records like this would reach Interpretation 1's view that Brown was 'above all the achievement of the NAACP's lawyers', who 'gathered the evidence of historians and psychologists' and argued the cases 'twice'. Source C, however, gives the view from a local community: the Moton students say the strike 'was our idea, not the grown-ups'' and that they contacted the NAACP only afterwards, while their parents agreed 'even though they knew what it might cost them'. This supports Interpretation 2, which says Barbara Johns 'only then asked the NAACP for help' and concludes that 'the courage of local communities made Brown possible'.
Explanation
Top answers suggest a clear reason, such as the use of different sources or a different focus (the national legal campaign versus the local communities where the cases began), and support it with precise details from both interpretations, matching them to Sources B and C where these are used. A common weakness is to repeat the main difference between the views without explaining why it exists. Comments about the dates of publication or the historians' bias earn nothing unless supported from the interpretations.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the authors have given weight to different sources. Source B, the Supreme Court's own judgment, presents the cases as legal arguments: the children act 'through their legal representatives', 'The plaintiffs contend' that segregated schools 'cannot be made "equal"', and the reargument 'covered exhaustively' the history of the Fourteenth Amendment in Congress and the states; a historian relying on court records like this would agree with Interpretation 1 that Brown was 'above all the achievement of the NAACP's lawyers', who 'prepared the school cases, gathered the evidence of historians and psychologists, and argued them twice'. Source C, in which the Moton students say the walkout 'was our idea, not the grown-ups'' and that they wrote to the NAACP only afterwards, while parents agreed 'even though they knew what it might cost them', supports Interpretation 2's view that 'the courage of local communities made Brown possible' and its point that Barbara Johns 'only then asked the NAACP for help'. They may differ because they focus on different stages of the case: Interpretation 1 concentrates on the national legal campaign from the 1930s and the arguments in the Supreme Court; Interpretation 2 concentrates on how the cases began in local communities (Clarendon County, Prince Edward County, Topeka). They may differ because of a different emphasis or scope: Interpretation 1 is a study of the NAACP and its lawyers, so it stresses strategy, expertise and money; Interpretation 2 is a study of the families, so it stresses the risks they took, such as losing jobs and credit. A strong answer may note that even Source B names the children as the ones who 'seek the aid of the courts'. An answer that explains one reason and supports it with details from both interpretations (and, where used, the matching source) reaches Level 2. Do not credit: assertions about the authors' dates, nationality or bias with no support from the interpretations; an answer that only describes the difference between the views (that is the 'main difference' question) without suggesting why it exists; statements such as 'Interpretation 1 supports Source B', which reverse the relationship.