Question 1
4 marksSource A: From the 'Declaration of Constitutional Principles', known as the Southern Manifesto, which was read out in Congress on 12 March 1956 and printed in the Congressional Record. It was signed by 19 senators and 77 members of the House of Representatives from eleven Southern states, and more members signed later.
We regard the decisions of the Supreme Court in the school cases [the Brown v. Topeka rulings of 1954 and 1955] as a clear abuse of judicial power. It climaxes a trend in the Federal Judiciary undertaking to legislate, in derogation of the authority of Congress [undermining the power of Congress to make laws], and to encroach upon the reserved rights of the States and the people. ...
This unwarranted exercise of power by the Court, contrary to the Constitution, is creating chaos and confusion in the States principally affected. It is destroying the amicable relations between the white and Negro races that have been created through 90 years of patient effort by the good people of both races. It has planted hatred and suspicion where there has been heretofore friendship and understanding. ...
We commend the motives of those States which have declared the intention to resist forced integration by any lawful means. ...
We pledge ourselves to use all lawful means to bring about a reversal of this decision which is contrary to the Constitution and to prevent the use of force in its implementation.
Give two things you can infer from Source A about the opposition of Southern members of Congress to desegregation in 1956.
Set out your answer under these headings, once for each inference:
What I can infer:
Details in the source that tell me this:
Model answer
What I can infer: Southern members of Congress were determined to overturn Brown v. Topeka, not just to delay it.
Details in the source that tell me this: They called the rulings 'a clear abuse of judicial power' and pledged 'to bring about a reversal of this decision'.
What I can infer: They wanted their resistance to look lawful and respectable, while encouraging the Southern states to defy the Court.
Details in the source that tell me this: They promised to use 'all lawful means' and praised the states that intended 'to resist forced integration by any lawful means'.
Explanation
Top answers infer the signers' attitudes and aims, for example that they rejected the Supreme Court's authority or that they wanted defiance to appear lawful, and support each inference with a short quotation. Repeating the Manifesto's claims is comprehension, not inference, and its claim of 'amicable relations' should be treated as the signers' view, not as fact. Own knowledge, such as the number of signers or who refused to sign, cannot be credited.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid inference about the opposition of Southern members of Congress to desegregation in 1956, e.g. they refused to accept the Supreme Court's authority over segregation / they presented their opposition as a defence of the Constitution and states' rights rather than of segregation / they denied that segregation harmed Black Southerners / they blamed the Supreme Court, not segregation, for racial tension / they encouraged the Southern states to resist desegregation / they wanted their resistance to appear lawful and respectable / they intended to overturn Brown completely, not just to delay it / they feared that the federal government would use force to integrate schools.
Award 1 mark for each valid inference up to a maximum of two inferences. The second mark for each example should be awarded for supporting detail selected from the source. e.g. Southern members of Congress refused to accept the Supreme Court's authority over segregation (1). They called the Brown rulings 'a clear abuse of judicial power' (1). They presented their opposition as a defence of the Constitution and states' rights rather than of segregation (1). The Court had acted 'contrary to the Constitution' and encroached 'upon the reserved rights of the States' (1). They denied that segregation had harmed Black Southerners, claiming that race relations had been good (1). They spoke of 'amicable relations between the white and Negro races' and 'friendship and understanding' (1). They blamed the Supreme Court, not segregation, for racial tension in the South (1). The ruling 'has planted hatred and suspicion' (1). They encouraged the Southern states to resist desegregation (1). 'We commend the motives of those States which have declared the intention to resist forced integration' (1). They wanted their resistance to appear lawful and respectable (1). They promised to use 'all lawful means' and praised resistance 'by any lawful means' (1). They intended to overturn Brown completely, not just to delay it (1). They pledged 'to bring about a reversal of this decision' (1). They feared that the federal government would use force to integrate schools (1). They promised 'to prevent the use of force in its implementation' (1). An inference must go beyond what the source says: 'they thought the decision was an abuse of power' simply repeats the source; the student must say what this suggests. The inference must come from Source A, not from own knowledge (e.g. '101 members eventually signed' or 'Lyndon Johnson refused to sign' is not an inference from the source). Answers that repeat or agree with the Manifesto's claims, instead of inferring the signers' attitudes, earn no credit. Accept other appropriate alternatives.
-
1 mark
Supporting detail selected from Source A that supports the first inference, e.g. 'a clear abuse of judicial power' / 'to encroach upon the reserved rights of the States and the people' / 'contrary to the Constitution' / 'amicable relations between the white and Negro races' / 'It has planted hatred and suspicion' / 'We commend the motives of those States which have declared the intention to resist forced integration' / 'by any lawful means' / 'to bring about a reversal of this decision' / 'to prevent the use of force in its implementation'.
Award only if the first inference has been credited and the detail genuinely supports it (a short quotation or close reference to Source A). A detail that does not support the inference given, or information from own knowledge, earns no mark.
-
1 mark
A second valid inference about the opposition of Southern members of Congress to desegregation in 1956, different from the first (see the examples under the first inference).
The second inference must be a different point, not the first reworded (e.g. 'they rejected the Supreme Court's ruling' and 'they did not accept Brown' are the same inference). Apply the same rules: no credit for comprehension or own knowledge.
-
1 mark
Supporting detail selected from Source A that supports the second inference.
Award only if the second inference has been credited and the detail from Source A supports it. The same detail may support two different inferences only if it genuinely shows both.