Question 1
4 marksInterpretation 1: From Kennedy's Choice: Civil Rights and the Presidency in 1963 by Grace Shalfleet (fictional), published in 2008.
Kennedy deserves more credit for his record in 1963 than he usually receives. In June he went on national television to describe civil rights as a moral question for the whole nation, and he backed his words with the most far-reaching civil rights bill ever sent to Congress. Over the summer his administration worked hard to build support for it, holding meetings at the White House with business leaders, churchmen, lawyers and civil rights leaders. In the autumn he brought the leaders of both parties to the White House and won Republican support for a compromise version in the House of Representatives. In twelve months he had turned civil rights from an issue his government avoided into the centre of its programme.
Interpretation 2: From Pushed into Action: The White House and Civil Rights, 1961-1964 by Thomas Ashprington (fictional), published in 1977.
Kennedy's record in 1963 was one of caution until events forced his hand. In February he sent Congress only a modest set of proposals, mainly about voting rights, and he moved decisively only after the violence in Birmingham had made the issue impossible to ignore. Even then he was anxious to keep control: he tried to persuade civil rights leaders to call off the March on Washington, fearing that it would turn Congress against his bill. The bill itself left out a ban on discrimination in employment, which many campaigners regarded as essential, and in the autumn his administration worked to weaken a stronger version drawn up by members of the House. His television speech was eloquent, but his actions in 1963 were those of a careful politician who was being pushed by the movement.
Study Interpretations 1 and 2. They give different views about President Kennedy's record on civil rights in 1963. What is the main difference between these views? Explain your answer, using details from both interpretations.
Model answer
The main difference is about whether Kennedy led on civil rights in 1963 or was pushed into it. Interpretation 1 argues that he 'deserves more credit' because he chose to act: he called civil rights 'a moral question for the whole nation', sent 'the most far-reaching civil rights bill ever sent to Congress', worked hard to build support for it and won 'Republican support for a compromise version', so that civil rights became 'the centre of its programme'. Interpretation 2, by contrast, argues that his record was 'one of caution until events forced his hand'. It says that he 'moved decisively only after the violence in Birmingham', that he tried to get the March on Washington called off, that his bill 'left out a ban on discrimination in employment' and that his administration 'worked to weaken a stronger version'. So Interpretation 1 sees a President who chose to lead, while Interpretation 2 sees 'a careful politician who was being pushed by the movement'.
Explanation
Top answers state the overall difference (a President who chose to lead on civil rights versus a cautious politician pushed into action by events) and support it with precise details from both interpretations, such as the 'moral question' speech and the attempt to call off the March on Washington. Answers that list what each interpretation mentions without saying how the views differ stay in Level 1.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): The interpretations are analysed and a key difference of view is identified and supported from them.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Limited analysis of the interpretations is shown by the extraction or paraphrase of some content, but differences of surface detail only are given, or a difference of view is asserted without direct support.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The main difference is that Interpretation 1 sees Kennedy's record in 1963 as one of real leadership that made civil rights the centre of his government's programme, whereas Interpretation 2 sees a cautious politician who acted only when the movement forced him to and who tried to limit what it demanded. Interpretation 1: Kennedy 'deserves more credit'; he called civil rights 'a moral question for the whole nation'; he sent 'the most far-reaching civil rights bill ever sent to Congress'; his administration 'worked hard to build support', with meetings with business leaders, churchmen, lawyers and civil rights leaders; he won 'Republican support for a compromise version'; he turned civil rights 'into the centre of its programme'. Interpretation 2: his record was 'one of caution until events forced his hand'; in February he sent 'only a modest set of proposals'; he 'moved decisively only after the violence in Birmingham'; he 'tried to persuade civil rights leaders to call off the March on Washington'; the bill 'left out a ban on discrimination in employment'; his administration 'worked to weaken a stronger version'; he was 'a careful politician who was being pushed by the movement'. Level 2 needs this difference of view (Kennedy as a leader who chose to act v. a cautious politician pushed into action) supported from both interpretations. A difference of surface detail only (e.g. one mentions business leaders and the other the March on Washington), or a summary of each interpretation in turn without stating the difference, stays in Level 1. Do not credit an answer that says Interpretation 2 denies that Kennedy proposed a bill: it accepts this and calls his speech 'eloquent'. Do not credit explanations of why the historians differ.