Question 1
4 marksSource B: From Justice, part of the 1961 report of the US Commission on Civil Rights, a body set up by Congress in 1957 to investigate the denial of civil rights. Here the Commission describes events in Montgomery, Alabama's state capital, after students from Alabama State College held a sit-in there in February 1960.
The first sit-in protest against segregation reached Alabama's State Capitol on February 25, 1960. On Saturday, February 27 it was reported, a group of 25 white men went through the downtown streets of Montgomery swinging toy baseball bats, and one of them attacked a middle-aged Negro woman. Allegedly, "the police made no arrests, although a news photograph of the episode, and the bat-swinging man, was taken." Two days later Governor Patterson declared: "There are not enough police officers in the United States to prevent riots and protect everybody if they continue to provoke [the white people] on that matter."
Sunday, March 6, 1960, at 2 p.m. was the time announced by Negro leaders for another protest meeting on the State Capitol steps. ... Montgomery city policemen were out in force. A crowd of perhaps 5,000 whites formed on the Capitol lawn. ... The police stopped the Negroes, but not the whites--some of whom attacked the Negroes, forcing them to flee.
Source C: From the same 1961 report of the US Commission on Civil Rights. Here the Commission describes how the authorities in Atlanta, Georgia, dealt with racial tension in 1960-61, when students held sit-ins in the city and its schools began to desegregate.
The leadership of Atlanta's Mayor William B. Hartsfield and Police Chief Herbert Jenkins have apparently had a deterrent effect on both police brutality and "private" violence. Last year Chief Jenkins told his men that regardless of personal feelings, they "must uphold the law" in matters of race relations. ... The conduct of Atlanta policemen in dealing with tense racial situations arising out of sit-ins, as well as their cautious use of force, has received the praise of white and Negro citizens alike. When four Atlanta schools were desegregated on August 30, 1961, the pattern was the same. Mayor Hartsfield, supported by civic and community leaders at all levels, counseled against violence. Chief Jenkins and his men took every precaution to prevent trouble before it started. Their objective was achieved.
Interpretation 1: From Hard Line: Southern Officials and the Student Protests, 1960-1961 by Laurence Fairbrother (fictional), published in 1985.
White officials across the South met the sit-ins with the full force of the law. More than 3,000 protesters had been arrested by the end of 1960, usually for trespass or disorderly conduct, while the white youths who heckled and attacked them were rarely charged. State governments joined in. In Alabama, Governor John Patterson made sure that nine students were expelled from Alabama State College after a sit-in at the Montgomery County courthouse, and several states rushed through new trespass laws to make sit-ins easier to punish. In Orangeburg, South Carolina, police and firemen used tear gas and fire hoses against hundreds of marching students. The message from those in power was clear: protest would be punished, and segregation would stand.
Interpretation 2: From Doing Business: Merchants, Mayors and the Sit-ins by Odessa Kingsworth (fictional), published in 2011.
White responses to the sit-ins were far from uniform. In many cities of the Upper South, and in some of the larger cities further south, mayors and businessmen decided that segregation at the lunch counter was not worth what it was costing them. Black shoppers' boycotts were cutting sales, and city leaders feared that disorder would drive away trade and investment. In Nashville, Mayor Ben West set up a biracial committee, and after a mass march in April 1960 he publicly agreed that it was wrong to refuse service to people because of their race; in May six downtown stores began serving Black customers. In Atlanta, Mayor William Hartsfield and his police chief insisted that order be kept without brutality, and in March 1961 business leaders agreed to desegregate the city's lunch counters. Where economic interests were at stake, quiet negotiation, not confrontation, was the choice of many white leaders.
Suggest one reason why Interpretations 1 and 2 give different views about how white leaders in the South responded to the sit-ins of 1960-61. You may use Sources B and C to help explain your answer.
Model answer
The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Interpretation 1 argues that white officials 'met the sit-ins with the full force of the law', while the white youths who attacked protesters 'were rarely charged', and Source B supports this. It reports that in Montgomery a white man with a baseball bat attacked a Black woman but 'the police made no arrests', and that at the Capitol 'The police stopped the Negroes, but not the whites'. Governor Patterson, whom Interpretation 1 names, even said there were 'not enough police officers' to protect everybody if the protesters continued to 'provoke' white people. Interpretation 2, however, argues that white responses 'were far from uniform', and Source C supports this: in Atlanta the mayor and police chief insisted that the police 'must uphold the law', and their 'cautious use of force' during the sit-ins was praised 'by white and Negro citizens alike'. This matches Interpretation 2's example of Atlanta, where leaders chose negotiation rather than confrontation. The historians have also focused on different places: Interpretation 1 on Deep South states such as Alabama, Interpretation 2 on cities such as Nashville and Atlanta.
Explanation
Top answers give a reason, such as the historians' use of different sources or their focus on different parts of the South, and support it by matching details in the sources to details in the interpretations, for example the Montgomery police with Interpretation 1 and Atlanta's leaders with Interpretation 2. Simply saying that one historian 'used Source B' without showing how it fits the interpretation stays in Level 1. Repeating the difference between the views, or claiming that one historian is biased, does not answer this question.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): An explanation of a reason for difference is given, analysing the interpretations. The explanation is substantiated effectively.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): A simple valid explanation is offered but displaying only limited analysis. Support for the explanation is based on simple undeveloped comment or on the selection of details from the provided material or own knowledge, with only implied linkage to the explanation.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The interpretations may differ because the historians have given weight to different sources. Source B, from the 1961 report of the US Commission on Civil Rights, describes Montgomery in 1960: one of a group of white men 'swinging toy baseball bats' attacked a Black woman but 'the police made no arrests'; Governor Patterson said there were 'not enough police officers ... to prevent riots and protect everybody if they continue to provoke' white people; at the Capitol 'The police stopped the Negroes, but not the whites'. This supports Interpretation 1's view that officials met the sit-ins with 'the full force of the law' while white attackers 'were rarely charged', and its example of Governor Patterson in Alabama. Source C, from the same report, describes Atlanta, where Mayor Hartsfield and Police Chief Jenkins insisted that the police 'must uphold the law', where the police handled the sit-ins with 'cautious use of force' praised 'by white and Negro citizens alike', and where civic leaders 'counseled against violence' when schools were desegregated in 1961; this supports Interpretation 2's view that white responses 'were far from uniform' and its example of Atlanta's mayor and business leaders. A student may note that both extracts come from the same federal report, which found very different responses in different cities, so the evidence can support both views. The interpretations may differ because the historians focus on different places and groups: Interpretation 1 on state governments and police in the Deep South (Alabama, South Carolina); Interpretation 2 on mayors and businessmen in cities such as Nashville and Atlanta. They may differ because of a different emphasis: Interpretation 1 on arrests, expulsions and new trespass laws; Interpretation 2 on economic motives (boycotts, 'trade and investment') and negotiated settlements. Level 2 needs a reason that is explained and substantiated, for example by matching details in the sources with details in the interpretations, or by showing the different focus from the content of each interpretation. Do not credit: answers that only describe the difference between the views (that is a different question); undeveloped claims that one historian is biased; speculation about the dates of publication or the titles of the books unless it is linked to the content of the interpretations.