Question 1
4 marksInterpretation 1: From Voice of the Nation: Malcolm X and the Rise of the Black Muslims by Raymond Swainby (fictional), published in 1969.
It was Malcolm X who turned the Nation of Islam from a tiny sect into a national movement. When he left prison in 1952, the Nation had a few hundred members, perhaps a thousand at most, and a handful of temples. Malcolm travelled tirelessly, setting up or reviving temples in Boston, Philadelphia and many other cities, and in 1954 he took charge of the temple in Harlem. His sharp, witty speeches on street corners, on college campuses and on television drew thousands of new followers, and he helped to launch the newspaper Muhammad Speaks. By the early 1960s the movement had tens of thousands of members. Without Malcolm's energy and talent, Elijah Muhammad's message would never have reached them.
Interpretation 2: From The Messenger's People: The Nation of Islam in Urban America by Lorraine Coxwold (fictional), published in 1997.
Malcolm X was the Nation of Islam's most famous speaker, but the movement's growth did not depend on him alone. Elijah Muhammad had built a disciplined organisation, with its own schools, businesses and guard, and its strict rules against drink, drugs and crime offered a way out for men leaving prison and young people trapped in Northern ghettos. Its message of Black pride and self-reliance spoke directly to the anger of migrants who had come North in search of a better life and found poor housing, low wages and hostile police. Every minister, Malcolm included, preached Muhammad's teachings and answered to him. The Nation grew because its message fitted the conditions of the cities.
Study Interpretations 1 and 2. They give different views about the importance of Malcolm X in the growth of the Nation of Islam. What is the main difference between these views? Explain your answer, using details from both interpretations.
Model answer
The main difference is that Interpretation 1 sees Malcolm X himself as the main reason the Nation of Islam grew, while Interpretation 2 argues that it grew mainly because of Elijah Muhammad's organisation and because its message suited conditions in Northern cities. Interpretation 1 says that 'It was Malcolm X who turned the Nation of Islam from a tiny sect into a national movement', describing him setting up temples and drawing 'thousands of new followers', and claims that without him Muhammad's message 'would never have reached them'. Interpretation 2 accepts that he was the 'most famous speaker' but says the growth 'did not depend on him alone'. It stresses Muhammad's 'disciplined organisation' and argues that 'The Nation grew because its message fitted the conditions of the cities', with Malcolm simply preaching 'Muhammad's teachings'.
Explanation
Top answers state the overall difference, Malcolm X's personal role against the organisation and social conditions, and support it with short quotations from both interpretations. Weaker answers summarise each extract in turn or point to surface details, such as one mentioning Boston and the other prisons. Explaining why the historians disagree is not needed for this question.
Mark scheme
-
4 marks
Levels of response (4 marks). AO4: 4 marks.
Level 2 (3-4 marks): The interpretations are analysed and a key difference of view is identified and supported from them.
Level 1 (1-2 marks): Limited analysis of the interpretations is shown by the extraction or paraphrase of some content, but differences of surface detail only are given, or a difference of view is asserted without direct support.
0 marks: No rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The main difference is that Interpretation 1 sees Malcolm X personally as the main reason for the Nation of Islam's growth, while Interpretation 2 argues that the growth was due mainly to Elijah Muhammad's organisation and to the way the movement's message suited conditions in Northern cities, with Malcolm as an important but dependent spokesman. Interpretation 1: Malcolm 'turned the Nation of Islam from a tiny sect into a national movement'; he set up or revived temples 'in Boston, Philadelphia and many other cities'; his speeches 'drew thousands of new followers'; 'Without Malcolm's energy and talent, Elijah Muhammad's message would never have reached them.' Interpretation 2: 'the movement's growth did not depend on him alone'; Muhammad 'had built a disciplined organisation, with its own schools, businesses and guard'; the message 'spoke directly to the anger of migrants'; Malcolm 'preached Muhammad's teachings and answered to him'; 'The Nation grew because its message fitted the conditions of the cities.' A Level 2 answer identifies this difference of view and supports it with details from both interpretations. Surface differences only reach Level 1, e.g. 'Interpretation 1 mentions Boston and Philadelphia but Interpretation 2 does not', 'Interpretation 1 gives membership figures', or 'Interpretation 2 talks about prisons'. Note that Interpretation 2 does not deny Malcolm's importance (it calls him 'the most famous speaker'), so an answer that says Interpretation 2 thinks Malcolm X was unimportant is an over-simplification. Do not credit explanations of why the views differ (that is a different question) or comments on the reliability of the authors.