Sampleford Research Ltd is a market research agency in Birmingham with 85 staff. It runs surveys and focus groups for food and drink brands. Its profit last year was £1.1 million, and it has no loans. More of its clients now want fast online surveys, so Sampleford wants to spend £1.8 million building an online research panel: a group of 50,000 people who are paid to answer surveys on their phones.
Sampleford owns its office and a separate viewing centre, which has rooms with one-way mirrors and video equipment where clients watch focus groups. The viewing centre is used on about 90 days a year, and an estate agent values it at £1.9 million, but selling it could take six to nine months. If it were sold, Sampleford could hire rooms in a hotel for focus groups at about £700 a day.
A bank is willing to lend it £1.8 million over ten years at 7.5% interest, with repayments of about £21,400 a month.
In order to finance the online research panel, Sampleford Research Ltd is considering two options:
Option 1: sell the viewing centre
Option 2: take out a bank loan.
Justify which one of these two options Sampleford Research Ltd should choose.
Model answer
Sampleford Research should choose Option 1, selling the viewing centre.
Selling an asset means there is no loan to repay, so Sampleford would avoid paying about £21,400 a month for ten years, which is about £2.57 million in total, including around £770,000 of interest. The viewing centre is used on only about 90 days a year, so it stands empty for most of the year. Hiring hotel rooms on those 90 days would cost about £63,000 a year, which is less than the interest on the loan, about £77,000 a year on average. Therefore Sampleford's costs would be lower and its profit higher, and because it would not have £257,000 a year of repayments to make, its cash flow would be much stronger and it would stay free of debt. As a result, it turns an under-used asset into the online research panel that its food and drink clients now want.
However, selling the viewing centre could take six to nine months, so the online panel would be delayed, and some clients who want fast online surveys might use another agency in the meantime. Also, hotel rooms do not have one-way mirrors or video equipment, so clients who like to watch their focus groups may be less happy, and Sampleford could lose some of this work.
Overall, Option 1 is better because it raises more than the £1.8 million needed without adding £770,000 of interest to Sampleford's costs. However, it depends on how quickly the viewing centre can be sold. If it looks likely to take the full nine months, Sampleford could start building the panel with part of last year's £1.1 million profit and finish it when the sale is complete; it could also offer clients video links from the hotel rooms so that they can still watch their focus groups.
Explanation
The best answers choose one option and weigh its benefits and drawbacks with the case figures: the £1.9 million valuation, the 90 days of use, the £63,000 of hotel costs and the £21,400 monthly repayments. The conclusion should add something new, such as how long the sale might take and how to cover the gap. Only the interest on a loan is a cost that reduces profit; the rest of each repayment affects cash flow, not profit. Either option can score full marks if it is justified well.