Aperwick Cameras Ltd designs and makes action cameras, small tough cameras that people fix to helmets, bikes and surfboards, at a factory in Livingston and sells them through electronics retailers and its own website. Its sales have fallen by 40% in five years as two much larger rivals have cut the prices of their action cameras, and in 2025 it made a loss of £1.6 million. Its main objective is now survival.
Aperwick sells 32 camera models. Its six diving and wildlife cameras, which the two large rivals do not make, still sell well and provide half of its revenue. Many of the other models sell only a few hundred a year, but each needs its own parts, packaging and marketing. Cutting the range to ten models would reduce costs by about £1.9 million a year, but revenue would also fall by about £0.8 million a year, and some retailers might give Aperwick less shelf space.
A water company has offered Aperwick a two-year contract to buy about 2,000 inspection cameras a year at £450 each, if Aperwick can design a tough, waterproof camera that its engineers can push through drains and sewers to find leaks and blockages. Aperwick could later sell the camera to other water companies and drainage firms. Designing it would cost about £600,000 and take a year, and Aperwick has never sold to business customers before.
In order to survive, Aperwick Cameras Ltd is considering two options:
Option 1: reduce its product range
Option 2: enter the market for inspection cameras.
Justify which one of these two options Aperwick Cameras Ltd should choose.
Model answer
Aperwick Cameras should choose Option 1, reducing its product range.
Cutting the range from 32 models to ten would reduce costs by about £1.9 million a year, because Aperwick would no longer need parts, packaging and marketing for 22 models that each sell only a few hundred a year. Revenue would fall by about £0.8 million, but profit would still improve by about £1.1 million. Therefore the £1.6 million loss would fall to about £0.5 million, so Aperwick would lose far less cash while it tries to survive. As a result, it could concentrate on its six diving and wildlife cameras, which already bring in half of its revenue because the two large rivals do not make them.
However, Aperwick would still be making a loss of about £0.5 million, and retailers might give it less shelf space if it offers fewer models, which could reduce sales of the cameras it keeps. Cutting the range also does nothing about the main problem: the two large rivals may keep cutting their prices, so sales of its remaining cameras could keep falling.
Overall, Option 1 is better because survival depends on cutting the loss quickly, while the inspection camera would cost £600,000 and bring in no revenue for a year at a time when Aperwick is already losing money. However, it depends on how quickly the smaller range cuts Aperwick's losses. If the savings arrive as planned, Aperwick could use some of them to develop the inspection camera next year and ask the water company to start the two-year contract then, giving it a market where it does not have to compete on price with the two large rivals.
Explanation
The best answers choose one option and weigh its benefits and drawbacks with the case figures: £1.9 million of savings against £0.8 million of lost revenue, the six diving and wildlife cameras that provide half of revenue, and the £600,000 and one-year wait for an inspection camera that might bring in £900,000 a year. A strong conclusion adds something new, such as using the savings from a smaller range to develop the inspection camera later. Either option can score full marks.