Corbelford Architects Ltd is a practice of 28 architects in Manchester that designs schools, libraries and health centres, mostly for councils. It made a profit of £640,000 last year. Its three directors want the business to grow, but it has been winning fewer new projects from councils, so they want to offer a wider range of design services.
Swalebrook Landscape Ltd is a firm of 20 landscape architects in Leeds that designs parks, playgrounds and school grounds. The two firms often work on the same projects. Swalebrook's directors would like to merge the two businesses. They would want an equal say in running the merged firm, and Swalebrook's staff mainly work from home, while Corbelford's staff work in the office.
Moirette Interiors Ltd is a studio of eight interior designers in Manchester that designs the insides of offices, hotels and restaurants for private companies. Its owner, who holds all of its shares, has offered to sell the business to Corbelford for £1.2 million. Corbelford would need a bank loan for £800,000 of the price. The owner, who wins most of the studio's work, plans to leave a year after the sale.
In order to grow, Corbelford Architects Ltd is considering two options:
Option 1: merge with Swalebrook Landscape Ltd
Option 2: take over Moirette Interiors Ltd.
Justify which one of these two options Corbelford Architects Ltd should choose.
Model answer
Corbelford Architects should choose Option 1, merging with Swalebrook Landscape.
The two firms already work on the same projects, so the merged business could offer councils a complete design for a new school or health centre, covering both the buildings and the grounds. This makes its bids more attractive than those of rivals that only design buildings. Therefore it may win a larger share of the council projects that are still available, even though Corbelford has been winning fewer of them. In addition, no price is paid in a merger, so Corbelford would not need an £800,000 loan. As a result, there would be no interest payments to reduce last year's profit of £640,000, and the merged firm would gain a base in Leeds, a new area in which to win work.
However, Corbelford's three directors would have to share control equally with Swalebrook's directors. Swalebrook's staff mainly work from home, while Corbelford's work in the office, so the two firms may disagree about how the business should be run, which could slow down decisions. Also, both firms rely on public-sector work, so the merger would not protect Corbelford if councils keep giving out fewer new projects.
Overall, the merger is the better option because it lets Corbelford grow without borrowing and builds on work the two firms already do together, while the takeover depends on keeping clients that were won by an owner who is leaving. However, it depends on whether the directors can agree how the merged firm will be run before they merge. If they set out clearly who will make which decisions and agree one policy on home working, the merger is likely to succeed; if they cannot, Corbelford might do better to look for a business to take over whose key people are staying.
Explanation
The strongest answers choose one option, use the case to explain its benefits and its drawbacks, and reach a conclusion that adds a new point, such as the 'it depends' factor about agreeing how the merged firm will be run. Listing the benefits of both options without comparing them gives no evaluation. Either option can score 9 marks if it is justified well, for example the takeover, because it brings a new market of private clients.