Question 1
1 markMagnesium chloride, MgCl₂, is an ionic compound. It melts at 714 °C.
Silicon tetrachloride, SiCl₄, is a simple molecular compound. It melts at -69 °C.
Which statement explains why silicon tetrachloride has a much lower melting point than magnesium chloride?
Choose your answer.
- A its covalent bonds are weak
- B its ionic bonds are weak
- C MgCl₂ has larger molecules
- D weak forces between its molecules
Model answer
D weak forces between its molecules
Explanation
Melting a simple molecular substance only separates whole molecules, so just the weak intermolecular forces are overcome and the strong covalent bonds inside the molecules stay intact. Melting an ionic compound means overcoming strong electrostatic forces between oppositely charged ions throughout the lattice, which needs far more energy. Saying that covalent bonds are weak, or describing an ionic compound as made of molecules, are common errors.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
D / weak forces between its molecules (1)
The only correct answer is D: when silicon tetrachloride melts, only the weak forces between its molecules (intermolecular forces) are overcome, which needs little energy; melting magnesium chloride means overcoming the strong electrostatic forces between oppositely charged ions in its giant lattice, which needs much more energy. A is not correct because the covalent bonds between the silicon and chlorine atoms are strong and are not broken when silicon tetrachloride melts; B is not correct because silicon tetrachloride is a simple molecular compound, so it contains no ions and has no ionic bonds; C is not correct because magnesium chloride is not made of molecules - it has a giant ionic lattice. Accept the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.