Discuss how far sociologists would agree that families and schools mainly pass on norms and values that are shared by everyone in society.
Model answer
Functionalists would largely agree with this claim. Parsons argued that the family performs primary socialisation, teaching children the basic norms and values of their society, such as honesty, politeness and respect for others. The school then acts as a bridge between the family and wider society: through the formal and hidden curriculum, children learn to follow rules, be punctual and be judged by universal standards. Durkheim similarly saw education as passing on society's norms and values, for example through teaching history, so that children feel part of something larger than themselves. For functionalists, this creates a value consensus that holds society together and maintains social order.
However, conflict theorists argue that the values passed on are not shared by everyone but serve powerful groups. Marxists claim that families and schools transmit ruling-class ideology. Bowles and Gintis argued, through the correspondence principle, that the hidden curriculum trains working-class pupils to be obedient and to accept hierarchy, preparing them for exploitation at work. Zaretsky saw the family as a prop to capitalism, socialising children as future workers and consumers. From this view, the apparent consensus is really false class consciousness.
Feminists add that families and schools pass on patriarchal values. Oakley described how parents channel children into gender-appropriate toys and activities (canalisation), and children often see mothers doing most of the housework. Schools may reinforce this through a gendered curriculum and teachers' expectations. These values are not shared equally because they benefit men at women's expense.
Interactionists question the idea that values are simply passed on at all. They argue that children actively interpret what they are taught; pupils may resist school values, as Willis's working-class 'lads' rejected the school's emphasis on qualifications, while labels from teachers can shape pupils' self-image in different ways, as Ball found at Beachside Comprehensive. In addition, Britain's cultural, religious and class diversity means families pass on different values, and peer groups and social media also compete with families and schools.
In evaluation, functionalism assumes a consensus rather than proving it and ignores inequality, while Marxism and feminism may overstate how passively people accept ideology, given that values such as gender equality have changed considerably since the 1970s. Some values, such as condemning violence, do appear widely shared.
Overall, most sociologists would agree only partly. Families and schools do pass on some widely shared norms, but the evidence of diversity, conflict and resistance suggests that many of the values they transmit reflect the interests of particular groups, especially the ruling class and men, rather than everyone in society.