Discuss how far sociologists would agree that changes in the status of women are the main reason for the rise in divorce since 1945.
Model answer
Feminists and many other sociologists would agree that changes in the status of women have been a major reason for the rise in divorce since 1945. Over this period, far more married women have entered paid employment and higher education, giving them their own income and reducing their economic dependence on husbands. The welfare state also made it more possible for women to support themselves and their children after divorce. At the same time, feminism encouraged women to expect equality in marriage, so many became less willing to accept the double shift of paid work plus most of the housework and childcare. Delphy and Leonard's argument that men exploit women's work in the family helps to explain this dissatisfaction. ONS figures support the claim: in 1950 divorces granted to husbands and wives were almost equal, but in 1993 wives were granted 118,401 divorces compared with 46,271 for husbands.
However, changes in the law were clearly important. The Divorce Reform Act 1969, which came into force in 1971, made irretrievable breakdown the only ground for divorce, and in England and Wales the number of divorces roughly doubled from 58,239 in 1970 to 119,025 in 1972. The Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984 allowed couples to apply after one year of marriage rather than three. Such sudden jumps suggest that the law released a demand for divorce that already existed, so it may explain the timing of the rise more than its underlying causes.
Changing attitudes and secularisation also played a part. As religion has lost influence, fewer people see marriage as a sacred, lifelong vow: in 2019, religious ceremonies made up only 18.7% of opposite-sex marriages in England and Wales. The stigma attached to divorce has weakened. Functionalists such as Fletcher argue that rising divorce reflects the greater value people place on marriage, as couples expect more fulfilment and are less willing to stay in empty shell marriages, while Marxists point to the economic pressures that capitalism places on couples.
A further problem for the claim is that divorce has generally fallen since its peak of 165,018 in 1993, even though women's status has continued to improve, which suggests that other factors, such as later marriage and the growth of cohabitation, also shape the pattern.
In conclusion, sociologists would largely agree that the changing status of women is one of the most important reasons for the rise in divorce, because it gave women both the means and the motivation to leave unhappy marriages. However, it is not the only reason: changes in the law explain the timing of sharp increases, and secularisation and changing attitudes worked alongside women's changing position. The rise is best explained by several connected factors rather than one main cause.
Explanation
Level 4 answers explain how women's changing status affected divorce, weigh it against the law, secularisation and changing attitudes, and use evidence such as divorce statistics. A common weakness is to list reasons for divorce without judging which is most important.