Discuss how far sociologists would agree that decision making and money management are now shared equally between partners.
Model answer
Some sociologists would argue that decision making and money management are now much more equal than in the past. Most women now do paid work, and many couples are dual-earner or dual career families in which both partners bring an income into the household. Equality laws such as the Equal Pay Act 1970 and the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 helped women gain more financial independence, and many couples now describe their decisions as joint and pool their money in a shared account. Functionalists would see these changes as families adapting to a modern society in which partners cooperate.
However, research on decision making suggests that equality may be more apparent than real. Edgell's study of 38 middle-class couples found that husbands dominated the decisions that couples saw as very important, such as moving house, finance and buying a car, while wives made less important decisions, such as children's clothes and interior decoration. Although Edgell's study is from 1980, decisions such as whose career takes priority, who reduces their hours after having children and who takes time off when a child is ill still often favour men.
Research on money management points the same way. Pahl identified different systems couples use. In the allowance system, the husband gives his wife money for housekeeping and controls the rest, while in the whole wage system, common in low-income households, the wife may manage all the money but mainly carries the stress of making ends meet. Even where couples pool their money, Vogler and Pahl's research on over 1,200 households suggested that the gendering of the breadwinner role continued, and control of the pool was often not equal. Managing money is therefore not the same as having power over it.
Feminists argue that these patterns reflect patriarchy. Oakley described how the conventional family made women economically dependent on men, and Delphy and Leonard argue that men benefit from women's work in the family. Because men still earn more on average, the higher earner's views may carry more weight. Marxists add that inequality in the home reflects wider economic inequality under capitalism.
There are important variations. Younger couples, dual career couples where incomes are similar, and same-sex couples may share decisions more equally; Dunne's research on lesbian couples found more equal sharing of paid and domestic work. Methodological problems also matter: couples may say they decide together because equality is now seen as the norm, even when one partner has more influence.
Overall, most sociologists would agree that decision making and money management are more equal than they were, but not that they are now shared equally. The evidence suggests that men still tend to have more control over major decisions and money, especially where they earn more, although the gap varies between couples.