Discuss how far sociologists would agree that people in Britain today are free to choose the type of family they live in.
Model answer
The Rapoports would largely agree with this claim. They argued in 1982 that Britain no longer had a single accepted pattern of family life and that a variety of family types was becoming accepted. Since then, legal and social changes have widened people's choices. Divorce is easier to obtain, cohabitation is widely accepted and civil partnerships (from 2005) and same-sex marriage in England and Wales (from 2014) have given legal recognition to same-sex families. Secularisation has reduced the influence of religious rules about marriage, and the decline in stigma means that people can live alone, cohabit or have children outside marriage; in 2022 more than half of births in England and Wales were outside marriage or civil partnership. Such diversity suggests that people now choose the family that suits them.
However, many sociologists argue that this choice is limited by social structures. Social class and income are major constraints: the Rapoports themselves identified class diversity, as a family's class position affects the resources available to it. High housing costs mean that many young adults cannot afford to leave home; the ONS estimated that 3.6 million people aged 20 to 34 lived with their parents in 2024. Many lone-parent families are created by separation or bereavement rather than chosen, and lone parents often face financial pressures that limit their options.
Gender also shapes choice. Feminists argue that women's choices are limited by lower average pay, the cost of childcare and the expectation that they will do most domestic work, so a woman who would prefer a dual career family may find that it is not practical. Oakley argued that the idea of the conventional family exercised social control, encouraging people to conform, and although she saw signs that this was weakening, people who live differently may still feel judged.
Culture, religion and the law also limit choice. In some communities, strong cultural or religious expectations shape marriage and family life, which the Rapoports called cultural diversity, although there is variation within every group. The law still restricts some forms of family: polygamy, which is legal in some other societies, is illegal in the UK.
The New Right takes a different view, arguing that too much choice has weakened the family. Murray, for example, saw the growth of lone-parent families as harmful to children and society, although critics argue that this view stigmatises lone parents and ignores the role of poverty.
In conclusion, most sociologists would agree that people in Britain have much more freedom to choose their type of family than in the past, especially in law and in social attitudes. However, the evidence suggests that this freedom is unequal and constrained by class, gender, culture and economic circumstances, so people are only partly free to choose the type of family they live in.
Explanation
Top answers use the Rapoports and evidence of legal and attitude change to support the idea of choice, then evaluate it with constraints such as class, housing costs, gender and culture before reaching a judgement. Answers that simply list family types without asking whether they are chosen do not address the question.