Discuss how far sociologists would agree that relationships between parents and children in Britain have become more equal.
Model answer
Many sociologists, particularly functionalists, would agree that relationships between parents and children have become more equal. Willmott and Young took a 'march of progress' view, arguing that family life has improved over time and become more democratic and home-centred. Families today are often described as child-centred: with fewer children and higher living standards, parents can invest more time, money and emotional attention in each child, and children are consulted on decisions such as holidays, clothes and bedtimes. Authoritarian parenting and physical punishment have become less socially acceptable, and children's welfare and views are given far more weight than in the past. The historian Aries argued that childhood as a separate, protected stage is itself a social construct that developed over centuries, which suggests that children's status within families has risen. Teenagers also have more independence through youth culture, part-time work, phones and social media, which give them information and friendships outside parental control.
However, other sociologists argue that 'more equal' exaggerates the change. Parents still hold most economic power: children depend on them for food, housing and money, and this dependency now lasts longer than ever. In England young people must stay in education or training until 18, and high housing costs keep many young adults in the family home into their late twenties. Parents also keep legal responsibility for their children and control rules and sanctions, such as curfews or confiscating phones, so relationships may be closer and more negotiated without being equal in power. Concern about safety may even have increased parental supervision compared with previous generations.
Marxists would add that child-centredness partly reflects capitalism: children have become important consumers, and parents spend heavily on goods aimed at them, so what looks like equality is linked to profit. Experiences also differ by social class, since parents living in poverty may have less time and money to devote to their children. Feminists point out that the work of negotiating with and caring for children still falls mainly on mothers, and that double standards may mean daughters are supervised more closely than sons, so relationships are not equal in the same way for all family members.
Overall, sociologists would largely agree that relationships between parents and children have become more democratic, emotionally close and child-centred than in the past. However, children's longer economic dependency, parents' continuing legal and practical authority, and differences by class and gender suggest that relationships have become more negotiated rather than truly equal.
Explanation
Level 4 answers weigh evidence of more democratic, child-centred relationships against parents' continuing economic and legal power, using perspectives such as functionalism, Marxism and feminism. A common weakness is to describe how childhood has changed without judging whether this amounts to equality.