Discuss how far sociologists would agree that unstructured interviews are the best method for researching family relationships.
Model answer
Many sociologists, especially interactionists, would agree that unstructured interviews are a very good method for researching family relationships. Family relationships are private, complex and emotional, and an unstructured interview allows each family member to explain their experiences in their own words. Because the interviewer can build rapport, people may be willing to talk about sensitive issues such as arguments, decision-making or feelings about caring for a relative. The interviewer can also follow up interesting answers, so issues the researcher had not expected can emerge. This produces rich qualitative data that are likely to be high in validity. Oakley's research with 40 London housewives, for example, gave a detailed picture of how women experienced housework, which helped to challenge the idea that families had become symmetrical.
However, unstructured interviews also have important weaknesses. They are time-consuming, so samples are usually small and may not be representative of the wide variety of families in Britain. Because each interview is different, it is hard to compare answers or for another researcher to repeat the study, so reliability is low. The interviewer's own characteristics may influence answers, and family members may present an idealised picture of their relationships to appear a 'good' family. Different family members may also give very different accounts of the same relationship.
Other methods may be better for some research aims. Structured interviews and questionnaires can collect quantitative data from large samples, allowing patterns to be compared between social classes or family types. Willmott and Young's large-scale social survey, in which nearly 2,000 people were interviewed using an identical set of questions, allowed them to identify broad trends such as the symmetrical family, although Oakley argued that their questions exaggerated men's contribution. Observation can show what family members actually do rather than what they say they do, though gaining access to private homes is difficult and the observer effect may change behaviour. Longitudinal studies can show how relationships change over time, and secondary sources, as used by the Rapoports and by Delphy and Leonard, allow many earlier studies to be compared.
In conclusion, sociologists would agree that unstructured interviews are one of the best methods for understanding the meanings and experiences behind family relationships, but not that they are the best method for every purpose. If the aim is to measure patterns across many families, structured methods are more appropriate. Many sociologists would argue that a mixed methods approach, combining unstructured interviews with questionnaires or observation, gives the most complete and valid picture of family relationships.
Explanation
Level 4 answers weigh the validity of unstructured interviews against their problems of representativeness and reliability, compare them with other methods using studies of families, and reach a judgement that depends on research aims. A common weakness is to list advantages and disadvantages of interviews without comparing them with any alternative.