Discuss how far sociologists would agree that the main gender problem in education today is the underachievement of boys.
Model answer
Since the late twentieth century, girls have overtaken boys in educational achievement, and many commentators now see boys' underachievement as the main gender problem in education. In England in 2022/23 girls had an average Attainment 8 score of 48.6, compared with 44.0 for boys, and girls were ahead in almost every ethnic group. More young women than men now go on to university. Sociologists have suggested several reasons for boys' lower achievement. Some boys' peer groups see hard work as uncool and 'feminine', so boys avoid being seen to make an effort. The decline of traditional male manual jobs may have created a crisis of masculinity, leaving some working-class boys unsure why qualifications matter. Others point to the feminisation of teaching, arguing that boys lack male role models, especially in primary schools.
However, feminists argue that this view ignores continuing disadvantages for girls. Girls' success in exams has not ended the gendered curriculum: far more boys than girls take physics and computing, and young women are concentrated in areas such as health and care, which are often lower paid. Despite their qualifications, women still face the glass ceiling and a gender pay gap at work. Feminists also point to sexism in schools. From this perspective the main gender problem is not boys' underachievement but the way education still channels young women into less well-rewarded futures.
Others argue that gender is not the main problem at all. The gender gap is smaller than the class gap: pupils eligible for free school meals averaged 34.8 in Attainment 8 in 2022/23, compared with 49.6 for other pupils, a difference more than three times the size of the gender gap. Ethnic differences are also larger. The concern about 'boys' may also be something of a moral panic: many boys achieve well, and because class and gender interact, it is particular groups of boys, rather than boys in general, who do least well. The gender gap at GCSE has also narrowed, from 5.5 Attainment 8 points in 2018/19 to 3.9 in 2025/26.
The claim can therefore be criticised for treating boys as a single group and for focusing only on exam results rather than on what happens to young people after school.
Overall, sociologists would agree only to a limited extent. Boys' lower average achievement is real and deserves attention, especially among some groups of boys. But because girls still face disadvantages in subject choice and later careers, and because class and ethnic differences in achievement are larger than the gender gap, it is too simple to see boys' underachievement as the main gender problem in education today.
Explanation
Strong answers use evidence on the gender gap and explanations for boys' underachievement, then evaluate the claim with feminist arguments and comparisons with class and ethnicity, reaching a clear judgement. Weaker answers to gender essays often ignore the gender element and write only about in-school and out-of-school factors in general.