Discuss how far sociologists would agree that official statistics are the most useful source of data for studying families in Britain today.
Model answer
Official statistics are numerical data produced by the government, such as the Office for National Statistics' figures on marriages, divorces, births and households, including the census. Many sociologists see them as very useful for studying families, but others argue that they give only part of the picture.
Official statistics have important strengths. The census covers every household in England and Wales and completing it is a legal requirement, and births and marriages must be registered, so the data are close to complete and highly representative. Because they are collected regularly in a standard way, they are reliable and show trends over time, such as the growth of cohabitation, lone-parent families and same-sex couple families, giving clear evidence of family diversity. They are also free and readily available, so a sociologist does not need to spend time and money collecting data from thousands of families. Functionalist, Marxist and feminist sociologists, who are interested in large-scale patterns in society, often rely on such statistics.
However, official statistics have serious limitations. They show what is happening but not why: divorce statistics show how many marriages end, but not why couples separate or how children feel. They record legal events, so the breakdown of a cohabiting relationship or a marriage that continues as an 'empty shell' does not appear. The categories are decided by government and may lag behind how people actually live; Oakley argued that official ideas of the conventional family were becoming outdated. Feminists also argue that statistics on households hide what goes on inside them, such as an unequal domestic division of labour or domestic abuse, which is often unreported.
For these reasons, many sociologists argue that qualitative data are more useful for understanding family life. Interactionists stress the meanings people give to their relationships, which unstructured interviews, observation or personal documents can capture. Non-official surveys can also be designed to ask exactly what the researcher needs: Willmott and Young interviewed nearly 2,000 people to investigate how roles in families were changing, something no official statistic recorded. The Rapoports built their account of family diversity by comparing existing research rather than relying on official figures alone.
In conclusion, sociologists would agree that official statistics are among the most useful sources for measuring the size and shape of families and how these are changing, because no other source is as representative or as regular. However, few would agree that they are the most useful source overall, because they cannot explain why families are changing or reveal relationships and inequalities inside the home. Usefulness depends on the research question, and many sociologists combine official statistics with qualitative methods.
Explanation
Level 4 answers weigh the strengths of official statistics, such as representativeness and trends, against detailed limitations and alternative sources, all applied to families, and judge how far they are the 'most useful'. A common weakness is to list advantages and disadvantages of official statistics in general without ever referring to family life.