Discuss how far sociologists would agree that the family in Britain today has lost most of its traditional functions.
Model answer
Some sociologists would agree that the family has lost many of its traditional functions. In pre-industrial Britain the family was a unit of production, as Willmott and Young described in the first stage of their model of family development: members worked together on the land or in cottage industries. Industrialisation moved production into factories and workplaces. Functionalists such as Parsons argue that, through structural differentiation, specialist institutions took over other functions too: compulsory state education means schools and teachers educate children, the NHS and hospitals provide health care, and the welfare state provides benefits and pensions that once depended on family support. Secularisation has also reduced the family's role in passing on religious beliefs.
However, Parsons himself argued that the family keeps two basic and irreducible functions: the primary socialisation of children and the stabilisation of adult personalities. These are arguably more important than ever, because the family is now the main source of emotional support in a fast-changing society. Fletcher, another functionalist, rejected the idea of loss, arguing that the welfare state supports families in carrying out their functions rather than replacing them. Families still provide a great deal of care for sick, disabled and elderly relatives, parents support their children's education through help with homework and the cultural experiences they provide, and some parents educate their children at home.
Marxists argue that the family has not lost its economic function but changed it. Zaretsky saw the family as a vital unit of consumption, buying the goods that capitalism produces, and as the place where housewives' unpaid domestic labour reproduces the next generation of workers. From this perspective the family's role in the economy is central, even though it no longer produces goods. Feminists point out that many of the functions the family keeps are carried out mainly by women: Delphy and Leonard argue that women's domestic work is appropriated by men, and women provide most childcare and care for elderly relatives. The functions that remain are therefore not shared equally.
There are also weaknesses on both sides of the debate. The idea of loss can exaggerate how much the pre-industrial family did, while the functionalist emphasis on emotional functions can present an idealised, middle-class picture: some families are dysfunctional and fail to provide emotional support at all.
In conclusion, sociologists would agree only to a limited extent. The family has clearly lost its role as a unit of production, and other institutions have taken over much formal education and health care. However, it keeps essential functions such as primary socialisation, emotional support and care, and it has gained economic importance as a unit of consumption, so its functions have changed and become more specialised rather than being mostly lost.
Explanation
Level 4 answers distinguish functions that have been lost, such as production, from those that remain or have changed, using Parsons, Fletcher, Zaretsky and feminist views. A common weakness is to list the family's functions without ever judging how far they have been lost.