Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
AQA GCSE Sociology (Paper 2) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
The sociological approach
Unit 2
Crime and deviance
Unit 3
Social stratification
Functionalist theory of stratification
Functionalist theory of stratification
Socio-economic class
Socio-economic class
Life chances
Life chances
Poverty as a social issue
Poverty as a social issue
Power and authority
Power and authority
Power relationships
Power relationships
Unit 4
Sociological research methods
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/14

The social construction of crime and deviance

Practise 35 exam-style questions on The social construction of crime and deviance for AQA GCSE Sociology (Paper 2). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 35 questions
  • 1–12 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

1 mark

What term is commonly used by sociologists to describe a label that comes to override a person's other identities, so that others see and treat them mainly in terms of it?

Choose your answer.

  • Master status
  • Role conflict
  • Status
  • Value consensus

Model answer

Master status

Explanation

Becker argued that a deviant label such as 'criminal' can become a master status, so that people respond to the person mainly in terms of that label. Status on its own simply means a position in society, and role conflict is a clash between the demands of different roles. The key idea is that the master status overrides everything else about the person.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Master status

    If more than one option is given, 0 marks.

Question 2

3 marks

Describe one way in which what counts as a crime has changed over time.

Model answer

Crime is socially constructed because the law changes as a society's norms and values change. For example, until the Suicide Act 1961 suicide was a crime in England and Wales, so people who survived an attempt could be prosecuted. The Act decriminalised it as attitudes moved towards seeing suicide as a matter for help rather than punishment. This shows that an act is not criminal in itself: it becomes a crime only when society defines it as one in law.

Explanation

Top answers give an accurate example of a law that has changed and explain why this shows that crime is socially constructed rather than fixed. Vague answers such as 'things that used to be legal are now illegal' with no example stay in Level 1. Inaccurate laws or dates are not credited.

Mark scheme
  1. 3 marks

    Levels of response (3 marks). AO1 = 3 marks.
    Level 3 (3 marks): A coherent description with few inaccuracies. Demonstrates good knowledge and understanding of relevant sociological theories, concepts, evidence and methods. (AO1)
    Level 2 (2 marks): A partial description based on a mix of relevant and irrelevant material with some inaccuracies and omissions. Demonstrates some knowledge and understanding of relevant sociological theories, concepts, evidence and methods. (AO1)
    Level 1 (1 mark): Fragments of knowledge, some inaccurate or irrelevant. Demonstrates limited understanding of relevant sociological theories, concepts, evidence and methods. (AO1)
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    Indicative content (AO1; not exhaustive, credit other valid points): Laws are made, changed and repealed as a society's norms and values change, so the same act can be legal at one time and criminal at another (crime is socially constructed); eg suicide was a crime in England and Wales until the Suicide Act 1961, so survivors of an attempt could be prosecuted; smoking in enclosed public places and workplaces became an offence in England from July 2007; controlling or coercive behaviour in an intimate or family relationship became a criminal offence in England and Wales in December 2015; new technology creates new offences (eg identity theft, online offences); changes may follow campaigns by pressure groups or moral entrepreneurs; credit other accurate examples, including from other societies. NB: Level 3 needs an accurate example and some explanation of why the change shows that crime is socially constructed. An example about deviance rather than the law (eg changing attitudes to tattoos) does not answer the question. Do not credit inaccurate laws or dates.

Question 3

4 marks

Item B
Howard Becker studied groups whose behaviour was defined as deviant, including marijuana users. He drew on his own experience of working as a dance musician in Chicago and on interviews with around fifty marijuana users. Becker found that people learned how to use the drug, and to enjoy its effects, from more experienced users in their group. He argued that deviance is not simply a feature of an act: social groups create deviance by making rules and applying them to particular people. He used the term 'moral entrepreneurs' for those who campaign for new rules, such as the officials who pressed for a law against marijuana in the USA in the 1930s.
Source: based on Becker, H S, Outsiders, 1963.

From Item B, identify and describe one way in which, according to Becker, rules and labels create deviance, including what you know of his perspective on crime and deviance.

Model answer

One way is through rule creation by moral entrepreneurs. Becker, writing from an interactionist perspective, argued that deviance is not a quality of an act but is created when social groups make rules and apply them to particular people. As Item B shows, moral entrepreneurs campaigned for a law against marijuana in the USA in the 1930s, so an activity that had been tolerated became a crime and its users became criminals overnight, although their behaviour had not changed. Agents of social control such as the police then have the power to apply the label to individuals and make it stick. Once labelled, a person may be treated as an outsider, and the label can become a master status that leads to a deviant career.

Explanation

Level 4 answers select a way, such as rule creation or labelling, describe it accurately using Item B, and state Becker's interactionist perspective. Without the perspective an answer cannot gain full marks, and answers that describe labelling in schools are capped. Precise terms such as moral entrepreneur, master status and self-fulfilling prophecy show strong knowledge.

Mark scheme
  1. 4 marks

    Levels of response (4 marks). AO1 = 1 mark, AO2 = 3 marks. 'Context' here refers to the work of Becker and his perspective on crime and deviance.
    Level 4 (4 marks): Relevant way selected (AO1) and an appropriate, detailed and well-developed description of relevant sociological theories, concepts, evidence and methods offered with a good application to the context. (AO2)
    Level 3 (3 marks): Relevant way selected (AO1) with a description of relevant sociological theories, concepts, evidence and methods containing some inaccuracies or omissions but which has some application to the context. (AO2)
    Level 2 (2 marks): Relevant way selected (AO1) with a largely inaccurate or irrelevant description of relevant sociological theories, concepts, evidence and methods that is only weakly applied to the context. (AO2)
    Level 1 (1 mark): Relevant way selected. (AO1)
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    Indicative content AO1 (not exhaustive, credit other valid points): Rule creation by moral entrepreneurs (new rules or laws make new deviance); labelling by agents of social control who apply rules to particular people; societal reaction: an act becomes deviant when others define it as such; master status; self-fulfilling prophecy; deviant career; deviance learned within a group. Indicative content AO2: Becker wrote from an interactionist perspective, focusing on small-scale interactions and the meanings people give to behaviour rather than on the structure of society; moral entrepreneurs campaigned for a law against marijuana in the USA in the 1930s, so users became criminals because a rule was created (Item B); whether a label is applied depends on who commits the act, when and where, who observes it and the negotiations between those involved; agents of social control such as the police and the courts have the power to make a label stick, and it may become a master status; the person may come to see themselves in terms of the label (self-fulfilling prophecy) and begin a deviant career ending in an organised deviant group; Becker's interviews showed that people learned to use and enjoy marijuana from other users, so deviant behaviour is learned in interaction. NB: Becker's interactionist perspective is required for 4 marks; without it, full marks can't be awarded. Answers about labelling in education only (eg teachers labelling pupils) are capped at 2 marks.

Question 4

12 marks

Discuss how far sociologists would agree that Merton's theory of anomie is a convincing explanation of crime.

Model answer

Merton, writing from a functionalist perspective, argued that crime results from the culture and structure of society. He started from value consensus: in American society almost everyone shares the same success goals, especially wealth. However, the culture stressed success far more than the legitimate means of achieving it, and people's positions in the social structure, such as their social class, meant that they did not have equal access to those means, such as good qualifications and well-paid jobs. The resulting strain could produce anomie, a situation in which the normal rules lose their force and 'anything goes'. Merton described five responses: conformity, innovation, ritualism, retreatism and rebellion. Innovation, where people accept the goal but use illegitimate means such as theft or fraud, was most likely among the lower classes.

There is evidence to support Merton. His theory links crime to inequality rather than to individual wickedness, and it helps to explain utilitarian crimes committed for money. It can be applied to modern Britain, where consumer culture and social media promote expensive lifestyles that many people living in poverty cannot achieve legitimately. Strain can even explain some white-collar crime, for example employees who falsify sales figures to meet targets.

However, many sociologists find the theory incomplete. Albert Cohen, also a functionalist, argued that much delinquency is non-utilitarian, such as vandalism, which brings no money and so does not fit innovation. Cohen also showed that delinquency is usually a group response: working-class boys who fail at school suffer status frustration and form subcultures that reward rule-breaking with status. Miller went further, arguing that lower-class culture has its own focal concerns, such as toughness and excitement, which challenges Merton's assumption of a value consensus.

Marxists argue that Merton ignores power. He does not ask who makes the laws and who benefits from them, and he takes the goals of capitalist society for granted. His theory also exaggerates working-class crime and underestimates white-collar and corporate crime, which Sutherland showed is widespread among respectable people. Interactionists such as Becker add that Merton relied on official statistics, which reflect who the police and courts label rather than who actually offends; Cicourel found that officers' typifications led them to focus on working-class youths. Finally, Merton is deterministic: he cannot explain why only some people facing strain turn to crime, or why women, who often have fewer opportunities, commit far less crime than men, which feminists such as Heidensohn explain through patriarchal control.

Overall, sociologists would agree only in part. Merton's idea that a gap between goals and opportunities creates pressure to deviate remains influential and fits some property crime well. However, because it ignores group subcultures, power, labelling and gender, most sociologists see it as one useful part of an explanation rather than a convincing explanation of crime as a whole.

Explanation

Level 4 answers explain Merton's theory precisely, using terms such as anomie, strain and innovation, then evaluate it with at least two other perspectives or theories, such as subcultural, Marxist and interactionist criticisms. A common weakness is to describe the five responses at length with little evaluation. The conclusion should weigh what the theory explains well against what it misses.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO1 = 4 marks, AO2 = 4 marks, AO3 = 4 marks. AQA's AO3 descriptor for each level opens the comments; judge AO1, AO2 and AO3 together (best fit).
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Detailed knowledge and understanding of relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods presented in a well-developed answer. A wide range of specialist terms used with precision. (AO1) Sustained application of relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods to the issues raised by the question. Few if any inaccuracies or omissions. (AO2) AO3: see Level 4 in the comments.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Good evidence of relevant knowledge and understanding of theories, concepts, evidence and methods but elements lacking detail and development. A good range of specialist terms used appropriately. (AO1) Good application of relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods to the issues raised by the question. Some inaccuracies or omissions. (AO2) AO3: see Level 3 in the comments.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Limited evidence of relevant knowledge and understanding of theories, concepts, evidence and methods. A limited range of specialist terms used appropriately. (AO1) Limited application of relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods to the issues raised by the question. Significant inaccuracies or omissions. (AO2) AO3: see Level 2 in the comments.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Fragments of basic knowledge and understanding of theories, concepts, evidence and methods relevant to the topic. Specialist terms generally used inappropriately if at all. (AO1) Little or no application of relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods to the issues raised by the question. (AO2) AO3: see Level 1 in the comments.
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    AO3 descriptors (AQA): Level 4: Developed critical analysis and evaluation of relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods. Well-constructed arguments with supported judgements and evidence-based conclusions. Level 3: Good evidence of analysis and evaluation of the relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods. A logical argument, but judgements and conclusions may be indistinct and/or lacking in appropriate development. Level 2: Limited attempt at analysis and evaluation of the relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods but lacking in appropriate development. There may be inconsistencies in the argument made and reasoning may be inaccurate leading to false or contradictory judgements and conclusions. Level 1: Little or no analysis of the relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods, assertion rather than evaluation, poorly-constructed argument with little or no evidence of substantiated judgements and only cursory conclusions. AO1, AO2 and AO3 are regarded as interdependent. When deciding on a mark all should be considered together using the best fit approach. For example, a level 3 mark could be awarded for level 3 evidence across each objective, or a mixture of 4, 3 and 2 evidence across different objectives.
    Indicative content (not exhaustive; credit other relevant points): AO1: Functionalism: Merton's value consensus, shared success goals, unequal access to legitimate means, strain, anomie and the five responses; subcultural theories (eg Albert Cohen's status frustration; Miller's focal concerns); Marxism; interactionism (Becker; labelling; official statistics; Cicourel); feminism (eg Heidensohn); white-collar crime (Sutherland). AO2: For: links crime to the structure of society rather than to individual wickedness; explains utilitarian property crime by people denied legitimate opportunities; can be applied to consumer culture and to target pressures in workplaces; explains different types of deviance (eg retreatism and drug use). Against: Cohen argues that much delinquency is non-utilitarian (eg vandalism) and a group response; Miller's lower-class focal concerns question the assumption of value consensus; Marxists say Merton ignores who makes the law and who benefits, and takes capitalist goals for granted; his theory exaggerates working-class crime and underestimates white-collar and corporate crime; interactionists say he relied on official statistics that reflect labelling (eg Cicourel's typifications); deterministic: cannot explain why only some people facing strain offend; cannot explain why women, who often face blocked opportunities, commit less crime. AO3: Analysis and evaluation of Merton's strengths and of each alternative; how far blocked opportunities explain different types of crime today; evidence-based judgement and conclusion on how far sociologists would agree that the theory is convincing. NB: Level 4: there must be some detailed discussion of at least one alternative explanation of crime as well as Merton's theory. A description of Merton's five responses alone, without evaluation, is Level 2 at most.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.