Discuss how far sociologists would agree that Merton's theory of anomie is a convincing explanation of crime.
Model answer
Merton, writing from a functionalist perspective, argued that crime results from the culture and structure of society. He started from value consensus: in American society almost everyone shares the same success goals, especially wealth. However, the culture stressed success far more than the legitimate means of achieving it, and people's positions in the social structure, such as their social class, meant that they did not have equal access to those means, such as good qualifications and well-paid jobs. The resulting strain could produce anomie, a situation in which the normal rules lose their force and 'anything goes'. Merton described five responses: conformity, innovation, ritualism, retreatism and rebellion. Innovation, where people accept the goal but use illegitimate means such as theft or fraud, was most likely among the lower classes.
There is evidence to support Merton. His theory links crime to inequality rather than to individual wickedness, and it helps to explain utilitarian crimes committed for money. It can be applied to modern Britain, where consumer culture and social media promote expensive lifestyles that many people living in poverty cannot achieve legitimately. Strain can even explain some white-collar crime, for example employees who falsify sales figures to meet targets.
However, many sociologists find the theory incomplete. Albert Cohen, also a functionalist, argued that much delinquency is non-utilitarian, such as vandalism, which brings no money and so does not fit innovation. Cohen also showed that delinquency is usually a group response: working-class boys who fail at school suffer status frustration and form subcultures that reward rule-breaking with status. Miller went further, arguing that lower-class culture has its own focal concerns, such as toughness and excitement, which challenges Merton's assumption of a value consensus.
Marxists argue that Merton ignores power. He does not ask who makes the laws and who benefits from them, and he takes the goals of capitalist society for granted. His theory also exaggerates working-class crime and underestimates white-collar and corporate crime, which Sutherland showed is widespread among respectable people. Interactionists such as Becker add that Merton relied on official statistics, which reflect who the police and courts label rather than who actually offends; Cicourel found that officers' typifications led them to focus on working-class youths. Finally, Merton is deterministic: he cannot explain why only some people facing strain turn to crime, or why women, who often have fewer opportunities, commit far less crime than men, which feminists such as Heidensohn explain through patriarchal control.
Overall, sociologists would agree only in part. Merton's idea that a gap between goals and opportunities creates pressure to deviate remains influential and fits some property crime well. However, because it ignores group subcultures, power, labelling and gender, most sociologists see it as one useful part of an explanation rather than a convincing explanation of crime as a whole.
Explanation
Level 4 answers explain Merton's theory precisely, using terms such as anomie, strain and innovation, then evaluate it with at least two other perspectives or theories, such as subcultural, Marxist and interactionist criticisms. A common weakness is to describe the five responses at length with little evaluation. The conclusion should weigh what the theory explains well against what it misses.