Item B
The Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings collects pay information from employers for a large sample of employee jobs in the UK. The table in Item B shows the median (middle) gross annual pay of full-time employees in selected occupations in 2025. The median for all full-time employees was £39,039. The survey does not cover the self-employed, and the 2025 figures are provisional.
Source: ONS, Annual Survey of Hours and Earnings 2025 (provisional), Table 14.7a.
Identify and explain one criticism of Davis and Moore's theory that is suggested by the pay figures in Item B.
Model answer
One criticism is that many jobs that are essential to society are poorly paid. Item B shows that care workers and home carers earned a median of £27,468 and refuse and salvage workers £27,857 in 2025, both well below the median for all full-time employees of £39,039. Yet society could not function without people to care for older and disabled people or to remove waste safely; during an outbreak of disease, for example, these jobs are vital to public health. Similarly, nursing professionals earned £43,078, less than solicitors and lawyers at £56,977, which raises the question of whether lawyers are really more important than nurses. If Davis and Moore were right, the most important jobs would receive the highest rewards, so these figures suggest that pay reflects other factors, such as the power of some groups to bargain for higher pay, rather than functional importance.
Explanation
A top answer identifies one criticism and supports it with accurate figures from Item B, explaining why they contradict the idea that rewards match functional importance. Answers that do not use the figures, or that misread them, are only weakly applied.