Item B
A team of sociologists gave an anonymous online questionnaire to 1,200 students aged 14 to 16 in eight secondary schools in one city (fictional study). Parents were told about the research and could withdraw their child. Students were shown a list of 15 offences, such as shoplifting, criminal damage and fare dodging, and asked which they had committed in the past year and whether they had ever been stopped or warned by the police. 58% admitted at least one offence, mostly minor ones. Students from middle-class and working-class backgrounds admitted offences at similar rates, but working-class students were twice as likely to say they had been stopped by the police.
Identify and explain one reason why official crime statistics may give a different picture of who commits crime from the findings in Item B.
Model answer
One reason is the way the police target their attention. Item B found that middle-class and working-class students admitted offences at similar rates, yet working-class students were twice as likely to say they had been stopped by the police. Official statistics only include offences that come to the attention of the police and are recorded, so if officers patrol working-class areas more and stop working-class young people more often, more of their offences will be detected. Interactionists such as Becker argue that agents of social control label some groups as typical offenders, and this label can make further contact with the police more likely. As a result, official statistics may exaggerate the share of crime committed by working-class young people, whereas the self-report study suggests that minor offending is spread across social classes.