Discuss how far sociologists would agree that Weber's view of social class is more useful than Marx's for understanding Britain today.
Model answer
Marx and Weber offered the two most influential theories of social class. Marx defined class by ownership of the means of production, while Weber defined it by market situation and added status and party as further dimensions of stratification. Sociologists disagree about which is more useful for understanding Britain today.
There are strong arguments for Weber's view. Marx predicted that the classes would polarise, with intermediate groups sinking into the proletariat, but in Britain the number of professional, managerial and technical jobs has grown enormously, as Weber expected. Weber's idea that people without property have different market situations, depending on the skills and qualifications they can sell, helps to explain the large differences in pay and life chances between, for example, a solicitor and a care worker, who in Marx's terms are both proletarians. The official NS-SEC, which groups people by occupation and employment conditions, is closer to Weber's approach. Weber's idea of status also helps to explain divisions based on lifestyle, education, ethnicity or religion, and his concept of social closure explains how professions protect their privileges. The Great British Class Survey, which identified seven classes using economic, cultural and social capital, also suggests that class is multi-dimensional.
However, Marx's view remains useful. Wealth in Britain is highly concentrated: ONS estimates suggest that the wealthiest 1% of households hold as much wealth as the least wealthy 50% combined. Marx's argument that ownership of capital brings economic and political power helps to explain the influence of a small wealthy class, which occupation-based measures such as the NS-SEC can hide. The growth of insecure and low-paid work, and Marxist arguments that many white-collar jobs have been proletarianised, suggest that exploitation continues. Marx's idea of ruling class ideology may also explain why many people accept large inequalities as fair.
Both theories face criticism. New Right thinkers argue that both ignore the opportunities and social mobility created by capitalism. Feminists argue that both focus on men's paid work and neglect gender, while others argue that class is now less important to people's identities than in the past.
In conclusion, many sociologists would agree that Weber's view is more useful for describing the detailed class structure of Britain today, because it explains the growth of the middle class, differences between occupations and the importance of status. However, Marx's view remains more useful for explaining the concentration of wealth and power at the very top. The most convincing understanding of class probably combines Weber's attention to market situation and status with Marx's focus on ownership and power.
Explanation
Level 4 answers explain both theories precisely, apply them to evidence about Britain today, such as the growth of the middle class, wealth concentration or status divisions, and reach a balanced judgement. A common weakness is to describe Marx and Weber in turn without ever assessing which better fits contemporary Britain.