Discuss how far sociologists would agree that the ideas of Durkheim, Marx and Weber are still useful for understanding Britain today.
Model answer
Durkheim, Marx and Weber wrote in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, in societies being transformed by industrialisation. Sociologists still study their work, but they disagree about how useful it is for understanding Britain today.
There are strong arguments that their ideas remain useful. Durkheim's concept of anomie, a lack of clear norms during rapid change, was developed by Merton to explain why some people turn to crime when they cannot achieve society's goals by legitimate means. Durkheim's concern with what holds society together also remains relevant to modern debates about community and shared values. Marx's analysis of class and exploitation still helps to explain large inequalities of wealth and income in Britain, and his idea of ruling-class ideology helps to explain why many people accept these inequalities. Later Marxists used his ideas to show how the law and its enforcement can favour the powerful. Weber's ideas may be the most relevant of all: his view that stratification involves status and party as well as class helps to explain inequalities based on lifestyle, occupation and ethnicity, and his analysis of bureaucracy describes modern organisations such as government departments and large companies.
However, Britain today is very different from the societies they studied. Marx predicted that the classes would become polarised and that a proletarian revolution would follow, but this has not happened in Britain; instead the middle class has grown, as Weber expected. The welfare state, rising living standards and social mobility have changed working-class life, and the New Right argues that capitalism has created opportunities that Marx ignored. Deindustrialisation and globalisation have transformed work in ways none of them could foresee.
Another limitation is that all three founders paid little attention to gender and ethnicity. Feminists have argued that society is stratified by patriarchy as well as class, and that crime and its control are shaped by gender, issues that classical sociology largely neglected. Interactionists also added the idea that crime and deviance depend on how people label each other, building on Weber but going far beyond the founders.
In conclusion, sociologists would largely agree that the ideas of Durkheim, Marx and Weber are still useful, because concepts such as anomie, class, exploitation, status and bureaucracy remain central to understanding crime and inequality in Britain. However, they would not agree that these ideas are sufficient on their own. Some predictions, especially Marx's, have not come true, and later perspectives such as feminism and interactionism were needed to explain aspects of society the founders ignored. Their ideas are best seen as foundations that later sociologists have built on.
Explanation
Level 4 answers assess the continuing relevance of specific ideas from at least two founders, using examples from crime and stratification, and weigh this against social change and later perspectives before reaching a judgement. A common weakness is to describe each founder's ideas in turn without ever discussing whether they still apply to Britain today.