Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
AQA GCSE Sociology (Paper 2) Smart practice A mixed round aimed at your weak spots
Unit 1
The sociological approach
Unit 2
Crime and deviance
Unit 3
Social stratification
Functionalist theory of stratification
Functionalist theory of stratification
Socio-economic class
Socio-economic class
Life chances
Life chances
Poverty as a social issue
Poverty as a social issue
Power and authority
Power and authority
Power relationships
Power relationships
Unit 4
Sociological research methods
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/14

Durkheim, Marx and Weber: consensus and conflict

Practise 30 exam-style questions on Durkheim, Marx and Weber: consensus and conflict for AQA GCSE Sociology (Paper 2). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 30 questions
  • 1–12 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

1 mark

What term is commonly used by sociologists to describe a set of ideas and assumptions about society, such as functionalism or Marxism, which shapes how a sociologist explains social behaviour?

Choose your answer.

  • Bias
  • Hypothesis
  • Propaganda
  • Theoretical perspective

Model answer

Theoretical perspective

Explanation

A theoretical perspective is a general approach to society, such as functionalism, Marxism, interactionism or feminism, which guides the questions sociologists ask and how they interpret evidence. A hypothesis is a specific, testable statement used in a particular piece of research.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    Theoretical perspective

    If more than one option is given, 0 marks.

Question 2

3 marks

Describe one way in which the changes taking place in France during Durkheim's lifetime shaped his concern with social order.

Model answer

Durkheim lived through rapid industrialisation in France, as people moved from small rural communities, where everyone shared similar lives and beliefs, to towns and cities with specialised jobs. At the same time, the influence of the Catholic Church was declining. Durkheim therefore asked what could hold a modern society together when tradition and religion were weakening. He argued that industrial societies depend on organic solidarity, people relying on each other's specialised work, but warned that rapid change could produce anomie, a lack of clear norms.

Explanation

A Level 3 answer links a specific change in Durkheim's France, such as industrialisation or the decline of religion, to his focus on social solidarity, shared values or anomie. Describing Durkheim's ideas without connecting them to the time and place he lived in is a common reason for losing marks.

Mark scheme
  1. 3 marks

    Levels of response (3 marks). AO1 = 3 marks.
    Level 3 (3 marks): A coherent description with few inaccuracies. Demonstrates good knowledge and understanding of relevant sociological theories, concepts, evidence and methods. (AO1)
    Level 2 (2 marks): A partial description based on a mix of relevant and irrelevant material with some inaccuracies and omissions. Demonstrates some knowledge and understanding of relevant sociological theories, concepts, evidence and methods. (AO1)
    Level 1 (1 mark): Fragments of knowledge, some inaccurate or irrelevant. Demonstrates limited understanding of relevant sociological theories, concepts, evidence and methods. (AO1)
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    Indicative content (AO1; not exhaustive, credit other valid points): France was industrialising and urbanising, so people moved from close-knit rural communities to anonymous towns and specialised jobs, leading Durkheim to ask what holds a modern society together (social solidarity; from mechanical to organic solidarity); the influence of the Catholic Church was declining in an increasingly secular Third Republic, so Durkheim looked for a new basis for shared values, eg moral education in state schools; rapid change could leave people without clear norms (anomie); political instability after defeat in the Franco-Prussian War and conflicts such as the Dreyfus affair increased his concern with social cohesion; his response was a consensus (functionalist) view stressing shared norms and values (collective conscience). NB: a general description of Durkheim's ideas with no link to the society he lived in is limited to Level 1 or 2.

Question 3

4 marks

Item B
Writing in Germany in 1904-05, Max Weber asked why modern capitalism first developed in parts of north-western Europe. He used statistics on religion and occupation in parts of Germany, which showed that Protestants were more likely than Catholics to own businesses or to have higher technical and commercial training, and he studied the writings of Protestant ministers. Weber argued that the beliefs of Calvinist Protestants made hard work, saving and reinvestment a religious duty, while spending on luxuries was frowned upon. This 'Protestant ethic' helped to create the 'spirit of capitalism'.
Source: based on Weber, M, The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism, 1904-05.

From Item B, identify and describe one way in which Weber's explanation of the rise of capitalism differed from Marx's, including what you know of Weber's perspective.

Model answer

One way was that Weber argued that religious ideas helped to cause the rise of capitalism, whereas Marx saw economic factors as the main cause of change. Item B shows Weber arguing that Calvinist beliefs made hard work, saving and reinvestment a religious duty, so ideas shaped how people behaved economically. For Marx, by contrast, the economic base of society shapes its ideas, and religion is part of ruling-class ideology rather than a cause of economic change. Weber's perspective was social action theory: he believed sociologists must understand the meanings behind people's actions, which he called verstehen. He therefore studied what Protestant beliefs meant to believers. Weber did not deny that economic factors mattered, but he argued that social change has many causes, not just class struggle.

Explanation

Full marks need a clear difference between Weber and Marx linked to Item B, together with an accurate description of Weber's social action perspective. A common weakness is to describe Weber's thesis well but never say how it differed from Marx, or to omit his perspective.

Mark scheme
  1. 4 marks

    Levels of response (4 marks). AO1 = 1 mark, AO2 = 3 marks. 'Context' here refers to the work of Weber with reference to his perspective, compared with Marx.
    Level 4 (4 marks): Relevant way selected (AO1) and an appropriate, detailed and well-developed description of relevant sociological theories, concepts, evidence and methods offered with a good application to the context. (AO2)
    Level 3 (3 marks): Relevant way selected (AO1) with a description of relevant sociological theories, concepts, evidence and methods containing some inaccuracies or omissions but which has some application to the context. (AO2)
    Level 2 (2 marks): Relevant way selected (AO1) with a largely inaccurate or irrelevant description of relevant sociological theories, concepts, evidence and methods that is only weakly applied to the context. (AO2)
    Level 1 (1 mark): Relevant way selected. (AO1)
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    Indicative content AO1 (not exhaustive, credit other valid points): Weber argued that ideas and beliefs (religion) helped cause economic change, whereas Marx saw economic factors (the means and relations of production) as the main cause; Weber saw many causes of social change, Marx mainly class struggle; Weber stressed the meanings that drove individuals' actions. Indicative content AO2: Weber's perspective is social action (interpretive): sociologists must understand the meanings people give to their actions (verstehen), eg Calvinists' anxiety about salvation and their sense of a calling; Item B shows hard work, saving and reinvestment becoming a religious duty, so beliefs shaped economic behaviour; Marx's historical materialism held that the economic base shapes ideas, including religion, which he saw as part of ruling-class ideology; Weber did not reject economic factors but rejected the view that they alone explain change (multi-causal); Weber wrote in Germany in the early twentieth century, engaging critically with Marx's ideas. NB: Weber's perspective (social action, interpretive or verstehen; accept a multi-causal view of social change) is required to obtain a mark; without it, full marks can't be awarded.

Question 4

12 marks

Discuss how far sociologists would agree that the ideas of Durkheim, Marx and Weber are still useful for understanding Britain today.

Model answer

Durkheim, Marx and Weber wrote in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, in societies being transformed by industrialisation. Sociologists still study their work, but they disagree about how useful it is for understanding Britain today.

There are strong arguments that their ideas remain useful. Durkheim's concept of anomie, a lack of clear norms during rapid change, was developed by Merton to explain why some people turn to crime when they cannot achieve society's goals by legitimate means. Durkheim's concern with what holds society together also remains relevant to modern debates about community and shared values. Marx's analysis of class and exploitation still helps to explain large inequalities of wealth and income in Britain, and his idea of ruling-class ideology helps to explain why many people accept these inequalities. Later Marxists used his ideas to show how the law and its enforcement can favour the powerful. Weber's ideas may be the most relevant of all: his view that stratification involves status and party as well as class helps to explain inequalities based on lifestyle, occupation and ethnicity, and his analysis of bureaucracy describes modern organisations such as government departments and large companies.

However, Britain today is very different from the societies they studied. Marx predicted that the classes would become polarised and that a proletarian revolution would follow, but this has not happened in Britain; instead the middle class has grown, as Weber expected. The welfare state, rising living standards and social mobility have changed working-class life, and the New Right argues that capitalism has created opportunities that Marx ignored. Deindustrialisation and globalisation have transformed work in ways none of them could foresee.

Another limitation is that all three founders paid little attention to gender and ethnicity. Feminists have argued that society is stratified by patriarchy as well as class, and that crime and its control are shaped by gender, issues that classical sociology largely neglected. Interactionists also added the idea that crime and deviance depend on how people label each other, building on Weber but going far beyond the founders.

In conclusion, sociologists would largely agree that the ideas of Durkheim, Marx and Weber are still useful, because concepts such as anomie, class, exploitation, status and bureaucracy remain central to understanding crime and inequality in Britain. However, they would not agree that these ideas are sufficient on their own. Some predictions, especially Marx's, have not come true, and later perspectives such as feminism and interactionism were needed to explain aspects of society the founders ignored. Their ideas are best seen as foundations that later sociologists have built on.

Explanation

Level 4 answers assess the continuing relevance of specific ideas from at least two founders, using examples from crime and stratification, and weigh this against social change and later perspectives before reaching a judgement. A common weakness is to describe each founder's ideas in turn without ever discussing whether they still apply to Britain today.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO1 = 4 marks, AO2 = 4 marks, AO3 = 4 marks. AQA's AO3 descriptor for each level opens the comments; judge AO1, AO2 and AO3 together (best fit).
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): Detailed knowledge and understanding of relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods presented in a well-developed answer. A wide range of specialist terms used with precision. (AO1) Sustained application of relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods to the issues raised by the question. Few if any inaccuracies or omissions. (AO2) AO3: see Level 4 in the comments.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): Good evidence of relevant knowledge and understanding of theories, concepts, evidence and methods but elements lacking detail and development. A good range of specialist terms used appropriately. (AO1) Good application of relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods to the issues raised by the question. Some inaccuracies or omissions. (AO2) AO3: see Level 3 in the comments.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): Limited evidence of relevant knowledge and understanding of theories, concepts, evidence and methods. A limited range of specialist terms used appropriately. (AO1) Limited application of relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods to the issues raised by the question. Significant inaccuracies or omissions. (AO2) AO3: see Level 2 in the comments.
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Fragments of basic knowledge and understanding of theories, concepts, evidence and methods relevant to the topic. Specialist terms generally used inappropriately if at all. (AO1) Little or no application of relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods to the issues raised by the question. (AO2) AO3: see Level 1 in the comments.
    0 marks: Nothing worthy of credit.

    AO3 descriptors (AQA): Level 4: Developed critical analysis and evaluation of relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods. Well-constructed arguments with supported judgements and evidence-based conclusions. Level 3: Good evidence of analysis and evaluation of the relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods. A logical argument, but judgements and conclusions may be indistinct and/or lacking in appropriate development. Level 2: Limited attempt at analysis and evaluation of the relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods but lacking in appropriate development. There may be inconsistencies in the argument made and reasoning may be inaccurate leading to false or contradictory judgements and conclusions. Level 1: Little or no analysis of the relevant theories, concepts, evidence and methods, assertion rather than evaluation, poorly-constructed argument with little or no evidence of substantiated judgements and only cursory conclusions. AO1, AO2 and AO3 are regarded as interdependent. When deciding on a mark all should be considered together using the best fit approach. For example, a level 3 mark could be awarded for level 3 evidence across each objective, or a mixture of 4, 3 and 2 evidence across different objectives.
    Indicative content (not exhaustive; credit other relevant points): AO1: Durkheim: social solidarity, collective conscience, anomie, functions of crime, social facts, functionalism; Marx: class, exploitation, alienation, ruling-class ideology, polarisation; Weber: social action, class, status and party, rationalisation and bureaucracy, life chances; later developments: Merton's anomie, Marxist criminology, interactionism, feminism, New Right; social change since their time (deindustrialisation, the welfare state, globalisation, the growth of the middle class, changes in gender roles and ethnic diversity). AO2: Still useful: Durkheim's anomie was developed by Merton to explain crime, and concern with social cohesion remains relevant to debates about communities and shared values; Marx's analysis of class and inequality remains relevant to wealth inequality and insecure work; Weber's ideas on status, life chances and bureaucracy help explain modern organisations and inequalities beyond class. Limited: they wrote in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries about societies very different from Britain today; Marx's predictions of polarisation and revolution have not come true and the middle class has grown (as Weber expected); all three paid little attention to gender and ethnicity, which feminists and others later addressed; the New Right argues that capitalism has created opportunity and social mobility; later perspectives such as interactionism and feminism added new ideas. AO3: Analysis and evaluation of each founder's continuing relevance to crime and deviance and social stratification, of how society has changed since they wrote, and of the extent to which later sociologists have built on or replaced their ideas; evidence-based judgement and conclusion on how far their ideas are still useful. NB: Level 4: there must be some discussion of at least two of the three sociologists and of how changes since their time affect the usefulness of their ideas.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.