Discuss how far sociologists would agree that poverty is caused mainly by the culture and behaviour of people living in poverty.
Model answer
Sociologists have long disagreed about whether poverty is mainly caused by the culture and behaviour of people living in poverty or by the structure of society.
Cultural explanations support the claim. Oscar Lewis, studying poor families in Mexico and Puerto Rico, argued that people in long-term poverty develop a 'culture of poverty' including fatalism, feelings of helplessness and a focus on the present. These values are passed on to children through socialisation, so poverty continues even when opportunities improve. In 1972 Sir Keith Joseph described a 'cycle of deprivation' passing disadvantage from parents to children. The New Right writer Charles Murray argued that generous welfare benefits created a culture of dependency and an 'underclass' with its own values, shown, in his view, by rising illegitimacy, crime and an unwillingness among some young people to look for work.
However, structural explanations challenge this view. Material deprivation, such as low income, poor housing and lack of resources, can explain why poverty continues across generations without any special culture: children in poor homes may have worse health and lower qualifications, which limit their chances of well-paid work. Many people in poverty are in paid work but on low wages or zero-hours contracts, so their poverty cannot be explained by an unwillingness to work. Globalisation and deindustrialisation have removed many secure manual jobs, leaving high unemployment in former industrial towns regardless of people's values.
Marxists argue that poverty is built into capitalism, because employers profit from low wages and a 'reserve army of labour' of unemployed people keeps wages down. They see ideas such as the 'underclass' as ruling class ideology that blames people living in poverty rather than the system. Feminists point out that women are more likely to be poor because of caring responsibilities, the gender pay gap and the fact that most lone parents are women, which are structural rather than cultural causes. Townsend's research on relative deprivation also showed that poverty was far more widespread than official figures suggested, affecting many groups, such as older people and those on low wages, who cannot be described as an underclass.
Critics of Murray argue that his evidence base was poor and that much research suggests most people in poverty have conventional attitudes and want stable relationships and paid work. Behaviour such as fatalism or poor budgeting may be a realistic response to poverty rather than its cause. On the other hand, structural explanations may underestimate the choices individuals make within their circumstances.
In conclusion, most sociologists would disagree with the claim. Culture and behaviour may sometimes help to keep people in poverty, but the evidence of in-work poverty, regional unemployment and gender inequality suggests that poverty is caused mainly by structural factors, with any distinctive 'culture' best understood as a response to poverty rather than its main cause.
Explanation
Level 4 answers explain cultural explanations accurately (Lewis, Joseph, Murray) and weigh them against structural explanations such as material deprivation, Marxism, feminism and globalisation, using evidence such as in-work poverty. They reach a clear judgement on 'mainly'. Answers that describe people living in poverty in stereotyped terms, rather than analysing explanations, lose credit.