Item A
A researcher wanted to find out whether defendants who had a lawyer were treated differently in magistrates' courts from those who did not (fictional study). Over three months she sat in the public gallery of two magistrates' courts and observed 120 hearings. She used an observation schedule to record, for each hearing, the type of offence, whether the defendant had a lawyer, how long the hearing lasted and the outcome. Defendants without a lawyer were more likely to plead guilty, and their hearings were shorter on average. The researcher did not speak to anyone involved in the cases.
Identify and explain one disadvantage of using an observation schedule, as in Item A, to research how defendants are treated in court.
Model answer
One disadvantage is that an observation schedule records what happens but not why. In Item A the researcher found that defendants without a lawyer were more likely to plead guilty and had shorter hearings, but the schedule only recorded fixed categories such as the type of offence, whether there was a lawyer, the length of the hearing and the outcome. It cannot show whether defendants without a lawyer pleaded guilty because they did not understand the process, felt pressured to get it over with, or simply accepted that they had committed the offence. Because the researcher did not speak to anyone involved, the meanings behind the pattern are lost, so the data lack validity as an explanation of how defendants are treated. Unstructured interviews with defendants and lawyers would be needed to add this depth.
Explanation
A top answer selects one disadvantage and applies it to the court study, showing what the schedule in Item A cannot reveal. Generic points about observation, or about quantitative data in general, are only weakly applied.