Discuss how far sociologists would agree that the media create moral panics about crime.
Model answer
Many sociologists argue that the media play a central role in creating moral panics. Stanley Cohen's study of the Mods and Rockers, which began with disturbances at Clacton at Easter 1964, showed how newspapers exaggerated minor incidents and presented the young people as dangerous folk devils. This created public alarm and calls for action, and the police responded with a crackdown. Cohen argued that the reaction amplified the deviance it claimed to oppose. Jock Young's study of marijuana users in Notting Hill showed a similar deviancy amplification spiral, in which press publicity and police action made drug use more central to the group's identity.
The media's role can be explained by news values. Journalists select stories that are dramatic, negative and easy to understand, and crimes involving young people or violence fit these criteria. Through agenda setting, repeated coverage makes an issue seem more widespread and serious than it is. Marxists such as Hall and his colleagues argued that the media and authorities created a moral panic about 'mugging' in the early 1970s, presenting young Black men as a new threat at a time of crisis for British capitalism, which diverted attention from economic problems and justified tougher policing.
However, the media do not act alone. Cohen himself described how politicians, the police and the courts joined in the reaction, so moral panics involve many groups who demand action, and the media may amplify concerns that others have raised. Some public concerns are not panics at all but responses to real problems: feminists argue, for example, that concern about violence against women and girls reflects genuine harm that was long ignored. Audiences are also not passive; people interpret media messages in different ways and may reject them.
The media landscape has also changed since the 1960s. People now get news from many sources, including social media, which may make it harder for a single newspaper-led panic to dominate, although social media can spread fear very quickly and allow rumours to circulate without checking. Functionalists offer a different interpretation, arguing that public outrage about deviance can reaffirm shared values and the boundaries of acceptable behaviour, so panics may reflect society's values rather than simply being created by the media.
Overall, sociologists would largely agree that the media play a major part in creating moral panics, through news values, exaggeration and the labelling of folk devils, as Cohen and Young showed. However, the media work alongside politicians, the police and other moral entrepreneurs, and some concerns reflect real harms. The most balanced conclusion is that the media are usually the main amplifiers of moral panics rather than their only creators.
Explanation
Level 4 answers explain how the media create moral panics using concepts such as folk devils, news values and deviancy amplification, and evaluate this with other perspectives, the role of other agencies, real concerns and changes in the media. Using Stanley Cohen's study is helpful, but strong answers go beyond simply retelling it. The conclusion should judge whether the media are the creators or the amplifiers of moral panics.