Priya is a 1500 metre runner. Last winter she had pneumonia and could not train for six weeks. This spring she has been stressed about her exams, but she has kept to her full training programme.
Analyse the relationship between Priya's health and her fitness.
Model answer
Health is a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being, and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity, while fitness is the ability to meet the demands of the environment. Priya's two periods of ill health show two different relationships between them.
Last winter, pneumonia left Priya physically unwell and unable to train for six weeks. This is decreased fitness because of ill health. Without training, reversibility set in, so her cardiovascular and muscular endurance fell and she would no longer have been able to meet the demands of a 1500 m race at her usual pace. Six weeks is a long break, and because pneumonia often leaves people tired for a while, she would have had to build her training up gradually, so it would take her weeks to regain her fitness.
This spring, exam stress means her mental well-being is poor, so she is not fully healthy. However, the stress does not stop her training. Because she keeps to her full programme, her body continues to adapt and her fitness increases. This is increased fitness despite ill health. Her stress might still affect her sleep and motivation, so her improvement may be smaller than if she were completely healthy.
So the key factor is whether the ill health stops Priya from training: the pneumonia did, so her fitness fell, but the stress did not, so her fitness rose.
Explanation
Top answers define health and fitness, link each period to one of the two relationships in the specification, and analyse why: inability to train leads to reversibility, while being able to train leads to adaptation. The best answers also judge what decides the outcome - whether training can continue. A common error is to assume that any ill health must reduce fitness.