Question 1
1 markPure heptane boils at 98 °C. Four students each measure the boiling point of the same sample of pure heptane three times, using distillation apparatus.
The table shows their results.
Whose results are both accurate and precise?
Choose your answer.
- A W
- B X
- C Y
- D Z
Model answer
D. Z's three results (97.9, 98.1 and 98.0 °C) are close to each other and close to the true boiling point of 98 °C.
Explanation
Accurate results are close to the true value; precise results are close to each other (a small spread). Results can be precise but inaccurate (W, probably a faulty thermometer), or have an accurate mean but poor precision (X). Students often treat accuracy and precision as the same thing.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
D / Z
The only correct answer is D: Z's results are all close to the true value of 98 °C (accurate) and close to each other (precise, a spread of only 0.2 °C). A is not correct because W's results are precise (101.4 to 101.6 °C) but all about 3.5 °C above the true value, so they are not accurate (this suggests a systematic error); B is not correct because X's mean (98.0 °C) is close to the true value but the results are spread over 6.2 °C, so they are not precise; C is not correct because Y's results are neither close to 98 °C nor close to each other. ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.