Question 1
1 markMethane causes much more warming than the same mass of carbon dioxide. A methane molecule stays in the atmosphere for about 12 years before it is broken down. Carbon dioxide stays in the atmosphere for hundreds of years.
Scientists say that cutting methane emissions would slow global warming within a few decades.
Which statement explains why?
Choose your answer.
- A the methane concentration would soon fall, as the methane in the air is broken down within decades
- B the methane concentration would soon fall, as methane absorbs less infrared than carbon dioxide
- C the carbon dioxide concentration would soon fall, as methane is broken down into carbon dioxide
- D the carbon dioxide concentration would soon fall, as carbon dioxide lasts only about 12 years
Model answer
A: the methane concentration would soon fall, as the methane in the air is broken down within decades.
Explanation
Because each methane molecule lasts only about 12 years, the amount of methane in the air responds quickly to a cut in emissions, so the extra warming it causes falls within a few decades. Carbon dioxide behaves very differently: it builds up over hundreds of years, so cutting carbon dioxide emissions stops the warming getting worse but does not reverse it quickly. Read the stem carefully: D swaps the lifetimes of the two gases.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A / the methane concentration would soon fall, as the methane in the air is broken down within decades
The only correct answer is A: if less methane is released, the methane already in the air is broken down in about 12 years, so its concentration (and the warming it causes) falls within a few decades. B is not correct because methane absorbs more infrared radiation than carbon dioxide (it causes more warming per tonne), and this would not make its concentration fall; C is not correct because cutting methane emissions does not remove carbon dioxide, and methane that is broken down adds a little carbon dioxide rather than lowering it; D is not correct because it is methane, not carbon dioxide, that lasts about 12 years: carbon dioxide stays for hundreds of years. ALLOW the letter or the option. If more than one option is given, do not award the mark.