Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of King John's treatment of William de Braose and his family in the years 1208-11.
Model answer
William de Braose had been one of John's favourites, but in 1208 John demanded his debts and his sons as hostages. The family fled, and in 1210 his wife Matilda and their eldest son were captured and died in royal custody, probably of starvation, while William himself died in exile in France in 1211.
Explanation
A full-mark answer gives one clear feature of the de Braose affair, such as John's demand for debts and hostages or the fate of the family, and adds a precise, factual detail. The deaths should be described soberly; vague claims that John 'killed everyone' gain little credit.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature identified, e.g. William de Braose had been one of John's favourites, rewarded with great lands in Wales and Ireland / in 1208 John demanded payment of the debts he owed the Crown (about 5,000 marks for Limerick) and hostages / his wife, Matilda, refused to hand over their sons, accusing John of murdering Arthur / John seized his castles and lands / the family fled to Ireland, and John's expedition of 1210 pursued them / Matilda and her eldest son were captured in 1210 and died in royal custody, probably of starvation / a sum of 40,000 marks was demanded in 1210, which the family did not pay / William fled to France and died in exile in 1211 / the case showed other barons how harshly John could act
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. William de Braose had been one of John's favourites (1): he had been given great lands, including Limerick in Ireland and three castles in Gwent in 1206 (1). / In 1208 John turned against him (1), demanding payment of about 5,000 marks he owed for Limerick and his sons as hostages (1). / Matilda de Braose and her eldest son were captured in 1210 (1) and died in royal custody at Windsor or Corfe, probably of starvation (1). / William de Braose fled to France (1), where he died in exile at Corbeil in August 1211 (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for his favour: lordships in Wales (Gower, Brecon, Abergavenny), Limerick, and the castles of Skenfrith, Grosmont and White Castle; he had captured Arthur at Mirebeau in 1202 and later had him in his custody; for John's demands: debts and hostages, then the seizure of his English estates and Welsh castles; for Matilda's refusal: Wendover reports her words about Arthur; for Ireland: the family were sheltered by the de Lacys, and John's expedition of 1210 was aimed partly at them; Matilda and her son were captured in Galloway; for the deaths: imprisoned at Windsor or Corfe; for the 40,000 marks: a sum the family did not pay; for William: an outlaw who joined Llywelyn, then fled to France; he was buried at the abbey of St Victor in Paris
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit graphic detail: the deaths should be described factually. Do not credit the claim that de Braose was executed. Accept 1210 or 1211 for the deaths of Matilda and her son (accounts differ).