Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the Saladin Tithe (1188).
Model answer
The Saladin Tithe was a tax of a tenth of everyone's income and movable goods for one year, raised to pay for the crusade. It was collected in each parish in front of the priest, the rural dean, a Templar, a Hospitaller and royal officials, and those who did not pay faced excommunication.
Explanation
A full-mark answer gives one feature of the tithe, such as its rate, who was exempt or how it was collected, and develops it with a precise detail, such as the presence of a Templar and a Hospitaller at each collection. Do not confuse the Saladin Tithe with the ordinary tithe paid to the parish church, or with the taxes raised later for Richard's ransom.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the Saladin Tithe identified, e.g. it was a tax of a tenth of income and movable goods / it was ordered by Henry II at Le Mans and proclaimed at Geddington in 1188 / everyone who did not take the cross had to pay / crusaders were exempt / some goods were exempt, such as knights' arms and horses / it was collected in each parish / a Templar and a Hospitaller were present at the collection / those who did not pay faced excommunication / rich townsmen were summoned and those who refused were imprisoned / the Jews of England were made to pay heavily as well / it raised a very large sum / it was unpopular
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. The Saladin Tithe was a tax of a tenth of each person's income and movable goods for one year (1), paid as alms to help the Holy Land after Saladin captured Jerusalem in 1187 (1). / Crusaders did not have to pay (1); anyone who took the cross was exempt, which encouraged people to join (1). / It was collected in each parish (1) in the presence of the parish priest, the rural dean, a Templar, a Hospitaller and royal and baronial officials (1). / People who did not pay faced excommunication (1); the archbishops, bishops and rural deans pronounced it in each parish against anyone who did not pay lawfully (1). / Henry II summoned the richest men of the towns (1), 200 from London and 100 from York according to Roger of Howden, and imprisoned those who resisted until they paid (1). / It raised a very large sum (1); Gervase of Canterbury says about £70,000 was collected from Christians (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the rate: a tenth of revenues and of movable goods (chattels) for the year; for the origin: agreed after Henry II and Philip II took the cross at Gisors (January 1188), decreed at Le Mans and proclaimed at the council of Geddington (February 1188); for exemptions: knights' arms, horses and clothes, the clergy's horses, books, vestments and church vessels, and precious stones were not counted; for crusaders: clerks and knights who took the cross paid nothing and received the tithe from their own lands and tenants, although burgesses and villeins who took the cross without their lord's permission still paid; for assessment: if someone was thought to have paid too little, four or six local men on oath decided what he owed; for the Jews: Henry II also took a heavy separate payment from the Jews of England (the chroniclers' figures are uncertain); for the sum: about £70,000 from Christians according to Gervase, the largest tax collected in England up to that time; for unpopularity: Archbishop Baldwin was blamed for its harshness; for Scotland: William the Lion refused to let it be collected, offering 5,000 marks instead
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or a general comment such as 'it was a lot of money'. Figures for the sum raised are uncertain: accept any figure given as an estimate (Gervase's £70,000 is the one most often quoted). Accept January or February 1188, and Le Mans or Geddington. Do not credit the ordinary tithe that every parish paid to its church each year, the tax of 1194 to pay Richard's ransom, or the tax of a thirteenth in 1207.