Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of Richard's imprisonment by Emperor Henry VI in the years 1193-94.
Model answer
Richard was put on trial before the emperor and his court at Speyer in March 1193. Henry VI accused him of betraying the Holy Land and of the murder of Conrad of Montferrat, but Richard answered so boldly that the emperor raised him up and gave him the kiss of peace.
Explanation
Full marks need one feature of the imprisonment, such as the hearing at Speyer, the visitors Richard received or his homage to Henry VI, and a precise detail that develops it. Retelling the legend of Blondel as fact, or confusing Henry VI with Leopold, gains no credit.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature identified, e.g. Henry VI took Richard from Leopold in early 1193 / Richard was accused before the emperor and his court and defended himself successfully / he was moved between several places, such as Trifels castle, Hagenau, Worms, Speyer and Mainz / he was treated as an important royal prisoner and allowed visitors / he went on governing his lands by letters and messengers / he wrote a song about his captivity / the emperor used him to bargain for a huge ransom / Philip II and John tried to persuade Henry to keep him longer / he had to do homage to Henry VI for England before he was freed / he was released at Mainz on 4 February 1194
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Richard was accused before the emperor's court (1); he answered the charges, such as the murder of Conrad of Montferrat, so well that Henry gave him the kiss of peace (1). / Richard was allowed visitors (1), such as Hubert Walter, whom he sent back to England to help raise the ransom (1). / He kept governing from captivity (1): he wrote to England urging his subjects to raise the ransom and had Hubert Walter chosen as archbishop of Canterbury in 1193 (1). / He was released only after doing homage to Henry (1): he surrendered England to the emperor and received it back as Henry's vassal, promising £5,000 a year (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the handover: agreed in early 1193 and carried out by March 1193; for the trial: at Speyer in March 1193, Henry accused him of betraying the Holy Land and of Conrad's murder, and Richard's reply impressed those present; for the places: Trifels (spring 1193), Hagenau, where Richard wrote that the emperor received him with honour, Worms, where the ransom terms were settled in June 1193, Speyer and Mainz; for the treatment: abbots sent from England found him at Ochsenfurt, his chancellor William Longchamp stayed with him and Hubert Walter visited him; William of Newburgh says Leopold had kept him in chains (accounts vary); for governing: he asked for the names of contributors to the ransom to be sent to him under his mother's seal; for the song: 'Ja nus hons pris' ('No man who is imprisoned') complains that his friends were slow to pay; for the bargaining: the agreed price rose to 150,000 marks; for Philip and John: they offered money to keep Richard until Michaelmas 1194; for the homage: on his mother's advice, according to Roger of Howden, he surrendered England and received it back for £5,000 a year; for the release: hostages, including the archbishop of Rouen, stayed behind for the unpaid balance
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second feature given in place of supporting information. Do not credit the story of Blondel finding Richard as fact (it is a later legend), claims that Saladin or Philip II held him, or that he was imprisoned for several years.