Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of King John's use of mercenaries in the First Barons' War (1215-16).
Model answer
John relied heavily on paid soldiers from abroad, led by captains such as Falkes de Breaute and Savary de Mauleon. Because mercenaries could fight all year round, John was able to campaign through the winter of 1215-16, when Falkes captured rebel castles such as Bedford.
Explanation
A full-mark answer identifies one feature of John's use of mercenaries, such as where they came from, who led them or their value for winter campaigns, and develops it with a precise detail. Avoid general definitions of mercenaries that say nothing about the war of 1215-16.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of John's use of mercenaries identified, e.g. John began recruiting mercenaries abroad in 1215, while he was still negotiating with the rebels / many came from Flanders, Brabant and Poitou / they were led by professional captains such as Falkes de Breaute and Savary de Mauleon / some of their captains were given royal castles and offices in England / many were lost in September 1215 when Hugh de Boves and part of his convoy were drowned in a storm while crossing to England / mercenaries took part in the siege of Rochester (1215) and John's northern campaign (1215-16) / unlike knights who owed forty days' service, they could fight all year round / their plundering of rebel lands made them hated / they had to be paid, so John needed large stores of silver / Magna Carta had promised to send foreign mercenaries out of the kingdom, so their use angered the barons
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. John relied on paid captains from abroad (1), such as Falkes de Breaute, who captured Hanslope and Bedford castles in late 1215 and was allowed to keep Bedford (1). / Many of John's mercenaries came from Flanders and Brabant (1); in September 1215 a convoy bringing troops from Flanders was wrecked in a storm and its leader, Hugh de Boves, was drowned (1). / Mercenaries could fight all year round (1), unlike knights who owed only forty days' service, which let John campaign through the winter of 1215-16 (1). / Their plundering made them hated (1): chroniclers hostile to John described his troops ravaging rebel lands in the north and in East Anglia (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for recruitment: John began hiring mercenaries from France in the spring of 1215, although some were sent back so that he did not look as if he wanted war, and in the summer Hugh de Boves raised more in Flanders and Brabant; for the captains: Falkes de Breaute and Savary de Mauleon, and other foreign captains such as Engelard de Cigogne; for Falkes: he took Hanslope (28 November 1215) and Bedford and held castles and sheriffdoms in the Midlands; for Hugh de Boves: a French knight who had raised troops in Flanders and Brabant, drowned in a storm in late September 1215, and Roger of Wendover says his body was washed ashore near Yarmouth; for campaigns: Rochester (October-November 1215), where Savary is said to have persuaded John not to hang the whole garrison, and the northern campaign of winter 1215-16; for payment: silver coin was stored in barrels in royal castles to pay troops; for Magna Carta: clause 51 had promised to remove foreign knights, crossbowmen and mercenaries once peace was restored; for 1216: doubts about the loyalty of his foreign troops may help to explain why John did not fight Louis when he landed
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second feature given in place of supporting information, or general comments such as 'mercenaries were soldiers who fought for money' without a detail about John's war. Do not credit the claim that John used no English troops, or confusion of John's mercenaries with Prince Louis's French army. Accept 'Brabancons' or 'routiers' for mercenaries, and any date in September 1215 for the loss of Hugh de Boves.