Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the role of sheriffs in collecting royal revenue in the years 1189-1216.
Model answer
Each sheriff owed the Exchequer a fixed yearly sum called the farm of his county, made up of rents and dues from the royal manors and other customary payments. He accounted for it at Easter and Michaelmas and could keep anything he collected above it, so King John often demanded extra payments, called increments, on top of the farm.
Explanation
Both marks need one clear feature of how sheriffs collected revenue, such as the county farm, their accounts at the Exchequer or the increments John demanded, developed with a precise detail. General statements such as 'sheriffs collected taxes' are too vague for the second mark.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature identified, e.g. each sheriff owed a fixed yearly sum, the farm of his county / the farm was made up of rents and dues from royal lands and other customary payments / sheriffs accounted at the Exchequer at Easter and Michaelmas / they could keep any money they raised above the farm / they collected other debts that the Exchequer listed, such as scutage, amercements and fines / King John made many sheriffs pay extra sums (increments) on top of the farm / some sheriffs were appointed as custodians who had to hand over all the revenue / the king appointed and replaced sheriffs, and many paid for the office
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Each sheriff owed the Exchequer a fixed yearly sum called the farm of his county (1). It was made up of rents and dues from the royal manors and other customary payments, and he paid part at Easter and accounted for the rest at Michaelmas (1). / Sheriffs collected other debts owed to the king (1); the Exchequer sent them a summons listing debts such as scutage, fines and amercements, which they had to collect and account for (1). / Under King John many sheriffs had to pay extra sums on top of the old farm (1). These increments were so resented that Magna Carta (1215) forbade them except on the king's demesne manors (1). / The king appointed and replaced sheriffs at will (1); in 1189 Richard I replaced many sheriffs and sold offices to raise money for his crusade (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the farm: a fixed sum set in the twelfth century; lands the king had granted away were deducted (the terrae datae) and the rest had to be produced each year; for the Exchequer: a sheriff who could not pay was held personally responsible for the shortfall, and his account was written on the Pipe Roll; for profit: sheriffs kept any surplus, so the office could be very profitable; for other debts: scutage, the debts of tenants, amercements from the courts and fines offered to the king; for the 1207 tax: special justices assessed it, but the rolls were handed to the sheriffs to collect; for increments: John demanded sums above the farm (accept 'profits' or 'increments'), and Magna Carta clause 25 later banned increments on county farms except on demesne manors; for custodians: custodians handed over all the county's revenue in return for a fixed allowance, so the king received any growth in revenue; for appointment: Richard replaced many sheriffs in 1189 and sold offices, and John often appointed trusted men, some of them soldiers from abroad, such as Philip Mark (sheriff of Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire), who was named for removal in Magna Carta
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or general comments such as 'sheriffs collected taxes'. Do not credit sheriffs as elected officials or as paid civil servants. Do not credit claims that sheriffs assessed the tax of 1207 (special justices did), though answers saying they helped to collect it are correct. Do not credit sheriffs acting as justices in their own counties after 1194, when this was forbidden.