Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of Richard I's conquest of Cyprus in 1191.
Model answer
Richard married Berengaria of Navarre at Limassol on 12 May 1191, during his conquest of Cyprus. She and his sister Joan had been on a ship that sheltered off Cyprus after a storm, and when Isaac Komnenos seized survivors and treasure from Richard's wrecked ships, Richard landed and took the island.
Explanation
Two marks need one clear feature of the conquest, such as its cause, its speed or Richard's marriage at Limassol, followed by a precise supporting detail. Do not confuse Cyprus with Sicily, where Richard spent the winter of 1190-91, and remember that Cyprus was a Christian island ruled by Isaac Komnenos, not by Saladin.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the conquest identified, e.g. it began when ships from Richard's fleet were wrecked off Cyprus / Isaac Komnenos, the ruler of Cyprus, seized survivors and treasure / Richard landed and took Limassol / Richard married Berengaria at Limassol / Guy of Lusignan and other lords came to meet Richard / the whole island was conquered in about a month / Isaac surrendered and was held in silver chains / Cyprus provided money and supplies for the crusade / it gave the crusaders a base on the sea route / Richard sold the island to the Templars and later to Guy / Philip II demanded half of Cyprus
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. The conquest began after a storm scattered Richard's fleet (1); ships were wrecked off Cyprus, and the ship carrying Richard's sister Joan and his fiancee Berengaria anchored off Limassol (1). / Isaac Komnenos, the ruler of Cyprus, seized the survivors and treasure from the wrecks (1), and when he would not return them Richard landed and took Limassol in early May 1191 (1). / Richard married Berengaria of Navarre at Limassol (1) on 12 May 1191, and she was crowned queen (1). / Richard conquered the whole island in about a month (1); Isaac surrendered and, because Richard had promised not to put him in irons, was held in silver chains (1). / Cyprus provided money and supplies (1), and Richard left men there to send wheat, barley and livestock to the army at Acre (1). / Philip II demanded half of Cyprus (1), because the two kings had agreed to share their gains, which added to their quarrel (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the storm: Richard's fleet left Messina on 10 April 1191 and was scattered soon afterwards; for Isaac: he called himself emperor, would not release the prisoners and goods, then broke an agreement and tried to resist; for Limassol: Richard entered Limassol on 6 May 1191 (accept 1-6 May); for the wedding: held in the chapel of St George at Limassol and attended by Joan; for the lords of the Holy Land: Guy of Lusignan, King of Jerusalem, came to Cyprus to win Richard's support against Conrad of Montferrat, and his troops helped to conquer the island; for the speed: the island was taken by about 1 June, and Richard sailed for Acre on 5 June 1191; for its value: Cyprus lay on the sea route to the Holy Land and stayed in Christian hands until the Ottoman conquest of 1570-71; for the sale: Richard sold it to the Templars, and in 1192 it passed to Guy of Lusignan, whose family ruled it for centuries; for Philip: he claimed half the island under their agreement to share conquests, but Richard refused
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second statement of the same feature in other words, or a general comment such as 'it was a great success'. Accept 'Isaac Comnenus' and 'Lemesos' for Limassol. Do not credit the claim that Cyprus was held by Saladin or by Muslims, or that Richard married Berengaria in England or Sicily. One chronicler suggested that Isaac was holding back supplies from the army at Acre, but most historians see the conquest as unplanned: credit either view if it is presented as a view.