Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the defences of Chateau Gaillard.
Model answer
Chateau Gaillard had three separate baileys, separated by deep ditches cut into the rock. An attacker coming from the only easy approach had to capture the outer bailey, then the middle bailey and finally the inner bailey and keep, each of which could be defended in turn.
Explanation
Full marks need one defensive feature, such as the three baileys, the rock-cut ditches or the curved inner wall, and a detail explaining how it worked or where it was. Answers that say only that the castle was 'strong' or 'hard to attack' gain one mark at most.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the defences identified, e.g. it stood on a high, steep rock above the River Seine / it had three separate baileys (enclosures), one behind another / the baileys were separated by deep ditches cut into the rock / the wall of the inner bailey was built as a series of curved projections / it had a strong keep inside the inner bailey / the keep had very thick walls / it had early stone machicolations / its towers allowed defenders to shoot along the walls / it was protected by outworks, such as a fortified island and a barrier across the Seine / the new town of Petit Andely was fortified too
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. It had three baileys (1), separated by deep ditches cut into the rock, so that attackers had to capture each one in turn (1). / The wall of the inner bailey was made of curved projections (1), which made it harder for siege engines to damage and let defenders shoot in many directions (1). / It stood on a steep rock about 90 metres above the Seine (1), so it could only be approached easily from one side (1). / It had early stone machicolations (1), openings at the top of the walls through which defenders could drop missiles on attackers below (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the site: a limestone promontory above a bend of the Seine, about 40 km from Rouen; for the baileys: the outer bailey faced the only easy approach, then came the middle bailey, then the inner bailey with the keep; for the ditches: deep dry ditches cut into the rock; for the curved wall: an unusual design that absorbed blows and allowed archers to cover the ground at the foot of the wall; for the keep: it contained the king's rooms and had walls several metres thick (accounts vary); for machicolations: among the earliest in western Europe; for the towers: round towers in the outer and middle walls gave flanking fire; for the outworks: a fort on an island in the Seine, a bridge and a stockade across the river, which could block boats coming down the Seine from Paris; credit weaknesses only if linked to a defence, e.g. the castle was overlooked by higher ground and needed a large garrison, and in 1204 the French got into the middle bailey through a latrine chute or chapel window
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit features of other castles, such as Dover or the Tower of London, or claims that it had cannons or a water-filled moat all round it.