Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the parts of England held by Prince Louis and the rebels in October 1216.
Model answer
Louis held London, where he had been proclaimed king at St Paul's in June 1216, and with the rebels he controlled most of the south-east, including Kent and Winchester.
Explanation
A full-mark answer identifies one feature of the areas Louis and the rebels held, such as London, the south-east or the north, and develops it with a precise detail, such as the capture of Winchester or the castles that held out. Avoid suggesting that Louis held the whole kingdom.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the areas held by Louis and the rebels identified, e.g. Louis held London, which he had entered on 2 June 1216 / he held most of Kent and the south-east, including Rochester and Canterbury / he held Winchester and much of Hampshire / the rebels held much of East Anglia / much of the north was in rebel hands, and Alexander II of Scotland, Louis's ally, had taken Carlisle / estimates of how much of England Louis and the rebels held range from about a third to more than half / royal castles still held out inside these areas, such as Dover, Windsor and Lincoln / the royalists held the west, the south-west and much of the Midlands
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. Louis held London (1), where he had been proclaimed king at St Paul's in June 1216 and where the barons had done homage to him (1). / Louis and the rebels held most of the south-east (1), including Kent, apart from Dover Castle, and Winchester, which he had taken in June 1216 (1). / Much of the north was in rebel hands (1), and Alexander II of Scotland, Louis's ally, had captured Carlisle in August 1216 (1). / Louis's control was not complete (1), because royal castles such as Dover, Windsor and Lincoln still held out in the areas he occupied (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for London: entered on 2 June 1216, where he was proclaimed (not crowned) king, with Westminster in his hands; for the south-east: Rochester, Canterbury, Reigate, Guildford and Farnham; for Winchester: it fell in June 1216 after a siege of about ten days; for East Anglia: it was rebel-held, which is why John's last campaign through Cambridge tried to separate it from the rebels in Lincolnshire; for the north: northern barons such as Robert de Ros, and Alexander II, who took Carlisle (August 1216) and did homage to Louis at Dover; for the size: about a third, or more than half, of the kingdom (estimates vary); for the royal castles: Dover (Hubert de Burgh), Windsor (which survived a siege of about two months) and Lincoln (Nicola de la Haye); for the royalists: the west, the south-west, the Welsh Marches and much of the Midlands
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second feature given in place of supporting information, or general comments such as 'Louis had a lot of land'. Accept any estimate from about a third to more than half of the kingdom. Do not credit the claims that Louis held Dover or the whole of England.