Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of the royal forests in the years 1189-1216.
Model answer
The royal forests were large areas where forest law protected the king's hunting. Inside the forest boundary it was an offence for anyone, even on land held by barons, to kill the king's deer or wild boar or to clear trees and undergrowth, and offenders were heavily fined by the king's forest officials.
Explanation
A full-mark answer gives one feature of the royal forests, such as the protection of the venison and the vert or the money kings made from forest fines, and supports it with a precise detail, such as the officials who enforced the law or Eleanor's release of forest offenders in 1189. Avoid relying on Robin Hood stories.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the royal forests identified, e.g. they were large areas where forest law protected the king's hunting / forest law protected the 'venison' (deer and wild boar) and the 'vert' (the trees and undergrowth that sheltered them) / it applied to everyone inside the forest boundary, even on land held by barons and churchmen, and included villages, fields and heath as well as woodland / special officials (wardens, foresters, verderers, regarders) and travelling justices of the forest enforced it / offenders were usually fined, and the forests brought the king money / kings sold exemptions and privileges / the forests covered a large part of England / forest law was hated, and the barons demanded reform in 1215
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. In the royal forests, forest law protected the king's hunting (1): it was an offence to kill red, fallow or roe deer or wild boar, or to clear trees and undergrowth, without the king's permission (1). / Forest law applied to everyone living within the forest boundary (1), including the tenants of barons and churchmen, so whole villages came under it (1). / The forests brought the king money (1): offenders were usually fined, although in 1198 Richard's justices of the forest announced that offenders would again face the old punishment of mutilation (1). / The forests were resented (1): in 1189, on Richard's orders, Eleanor released those imprisoned for forest offences and allowed those outlawed for them to return, a popular start to the new reign (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the venison: red, fallow and roe deer and wild boar; for the vert: trees and undergrowth, so clearing land for farming (assarting) was an offence; for extent: at their height in the late twelfth and early thirteenth centuries the forests covered perhaps a third of southern England, and at one stage in the twelfth century the whole of Essex was forest; for officials: wardens, foresters, verderers, regarders, and the justices of the forest such as Hugh Neville; for penalties: fines on goods and chattels, with Richard's forest eyre of 1198 threatening mutilation; for rules: dogs, bows and arrows were banned in the forest without permission; for money: kings sold exemptions, such as those Richard granted to the Archbishop of York's lands in 1189; for 1189: the release of forest offenders; for resentment: Magna Carta (1215) included several clauses on the forests, and the Charter of the Forest followed in 1217
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second feature given in place of supporting information, or general comments such as 'the king liked hunting'. Do not credit Robin Hood legends as evidence, or the claim that the forests were only thick woodland. Accept 'a quarter to a third' or 'a large part' of England for their extent, but do not require a figure. Accept 'the king's hunting grounds' for the forests.