Question 1
2 marksDescribe one feature of King John's expulsion of the monks of Christ Church, Canterbury, in 1207.
Model answer
In July 1207 John drove the monks of Christ Church, Canterbury, out of England because they had elected Stephen Langton as archbishop. Two of his knights entered the monastery with armed men and, according to Roger of Wendover, threatened to burn it, so the monks went into exile in Flanders.
Explanation
A full-mark answer identifies one feature of the expulsion, such as John's accusation of treason, the threat used against the monks or their exile in Flanders, and develops it with a precise detail. Keep to the events of 1207 rather than describing the Interdict or the flight of the bishops, and treat Wendover's details as his account.
Mark scheme
-
1 mark
A valid feature of the expulsion identified, e.g. it took place in July 1207, soon after the Pope consecrated Stephen Langton as archbishop / John accused the monks of treason because they had elected Langton in Rome / he sent two knights, Fulk de Cantilupe and Henry of Cornhill, with armed men to Canterbury / the monks were ordered to leave the kingdom at once / the knights threatened to burn the monastery with the monks inside if they refused / almost all the monks left England, except a few who were too ill to travel / the exiles were received at the abbey of St Bertin at Saint-Omer in Flanders and in other monasteries / the property of the monks and the lands of the archbishopric were seized / other monks were brought in to serve the cathedral / it was one of the actions that led Innocent III to place England under an Interdict in 1208
Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. John accused the monks of treason (1), because the monks who had gone to Rome had elected Stephen Langton, whom John refused to accept, and the Pope had consecrated him in June 1207 (1). / John sent two knights with armed men to drive the monks out (1); according to Roger of Wendover, Fulk de Cantilupe and Henry of Cornhill entered the monastery with drawn swords and threatened to burn it with the monks inside (1). / The monks went into exile in Flanders (1), where they were received at the abbey of St Bertin at Saint-Omer and in other monasteries (1). / The king seized the monks' property (1); Wendover says that Fulk de Cantilupe took control of it and that the lands of the monks and of the archbishop were left uncultivated (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.
-
1 mark
Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the date: July 1207 (Roger of Wendover gives 14 July; other accounts 15 July); for the reason: John said the monks had betrayed him by electing their subprior Reginald without his consent, then electing John de Gray, and finally electing Langton in Rome in December 1206; for the knights: Fulk de Cantilupe and Henry of Cornhill, whom Wendover calls 'most cruel and inhuman knights'; for the threat: they swore to set fire to the monastery and its buildings and burn the monks with them; for the exiles: according to Wendover all left except thirteen sick monks in the infirmary; for Flanders: the abbey of St Bertin at Saint-Omer; for the property: Fulk managed and seized the monks' goods, and their lands and the archbishop's were left uncultivated; for the replacements: Wendover says monks of the order of St Augustine were brought in to serve the church; for its significance: with the monks expelled, Langton kept out of England and the archbishop's lands seized, Innocent III placed England under an Interdict in March 1208
The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second feature given in place of supporting information, or general comments such as 'John was angry'. Do not credit confusion with the flight of the bishops (1208-09) or with the Interdict itself, or the claim that the monks were killed. Accept 14 or 15 July 1207, or 'the summer of 1207'. Accept 'Fulk de Cantelu' for Fulk de Cantilupe.