Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/12

John's dispute with the Papacy

Practise 22 exam-style questions on John's dispute with the Papacy for Edexcel GCSE History (The reigns of King Richard I and King John 1189-1216). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 22 questions
  • 2–16 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
20 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

2 marks

Describe one feature of King John's expulsion of the monks of Christ Church, Canterbury, in 1207.

Model answer

In July 1207 John drove the monks of Christ Church, Canterbury, out of England because they had elected Stephen Langton as archbishop. Two of his knights entered the monastery with armed men and, according to Roger of Wendover, threatened to burn it, so the monks went into exile in Flanders.

Explanation

A full-mark answer identifies one feature of the expulsion, such as John's accusation of treason, the threat used against the monks or their exile in Flanders, and develops it with a precise detail. Keep to the events of 1207 rather than describing the Interdict or the flight of the bishops, and treat Wendover's details as his account.

Mark scheme
  1. 1 mark

    A valid feature of the expulsion identified, e.g. it took place in July 1207, soon after the Pope consecrated Stephen Langton as archbishop / John accused the monks of treason because they had elected Langton in Rome / he sent two knights, Fulk de Cantilupe and Henry of Cornhill, with armed men to Canterbury / the monks were ordered to leave the kingdom at once / the knights threatened to burn the monastery with the monks inside if they refused / almost all the monks left England, except a few who were too ill to travel / the exiles were received at the abbey of St Bertin at Saint-Omer in Flanders and in other monasteries / the property of the monks and the lands of the archbishopric were seized / other monks were brought in to serve the cathedral / it was one of the actions that led Innocent III to place England under an Interdict in 1208

    Award 1 mark for a valid feature identified. The second mark should be awarded for supporting information. e.g. John accused the monks of treason (1), because the monks who had gone to Rome had elected Stephen Langton, whom John refused to accept, and the Pope had consecrated him in June 1207 (1). / John sent two knights with armed men to drive the monks out (1); according to Roger of Wendover, Fulk de Cantilupe and Henry of Cornhill entered the monastery with drawn swords and threatened to burn it with the monks inside (1). / The monks went into exile in Flanders (1), where they were received at the abbey of St Bertin at Saint-Omer and in other monasteries (1). / The king seized the monks' property (1); Wendover says that Fulk de Cantilupe took control of it and that the lands of the monks and of the archbishop were left uncultivated (1). Accept other appropriate features and supporting information.

  2. 1 mark

    Supporting information that develops the feature identified, e.g. for the date: July 1207 (Roger of Wendover gives 14 July; other accounts 15 July); for the reason: John said the monks had betrayed him by electing their subprior Reginald without his consent, then electing John de Gray, and finally electing Langton in Rome in December 1206; for the knights: Fulk de Cantilupe and Henry of Cornhill, whom Wendover calls 'most cruel and inhuman knights'; for the threat: they swore to set fire to the monastery and its buildings and burn the monks with them; for the exiles: according to Wendover all left except thirteen sick monks in the infirmary; for Flanders: the abbey of St Bertin at Saint-Omer; for the property: Fulk managed and seized the monks' goods, and their lands and the archbishop's were left uncultivated; for the replacements: Wendover says monks of the order of St Augustine were brought in to serve the church; for its significance: with the monks expelled, Langton kept out of England and the archbishop's lands seized, Innocent III placed England under an Interdict in March 1208

    The supporting information must develop the feature already identified. Do not credit a second feature given in place of supporting information, or general comments such as 'John was angry'. Do not credit confusion with the flight of the bishops (1208-09) or with the Interdict itself, or the claim that the monks were killed. Accept 14 or 15 July 1207, or 'the summer of 1207'. Accept 'Fulk de Cantelu' for Fulk de Cantilupe.

Question 2

12 marks

Explain why King John refused to accept Stephen Langton as Archbishop of Canterbury.

You may use the following in your answer:
- John de Gray
- the king's customary rights

You must also use information of your own.

Model answer

John refused to accept Stephen Langton because he believed that the Pope had overridden his rights as king, because he wanted his own trusted servant as archbishop, and because he distrusted Langton himself.

The most important reason was John's belief that his customary rights had been ignored. Norman and Angevin kings had always had a decisive say in choosing the Archbishop of Canterbury. This mattered because the archbishop was far more than a churchman: he was a tenant-in-chief with great estates and knights, he crowned the king, and he was usually one of the king's chief advisers. Hubert Walter, who died in July 1205, had been both justiciar and chancellor. Langton, however, was elected by Canterbury monks in Rome in December 1206, in the Pope's presence, and John complained that his consent had never properly been asked. When Innocent consecrated Langton at Viterbo in June 1207, John saw it as an attack on the rights of the Crown.

Second, John already had his own candidate, John de Gray, Bishop of Norwich. De Gray was one of the king's most trusted servants and a skilled fundraiser, and in December 1205 John had made the Canterbury monks elect him. John had been angered when some of the monks secretly chose their subprior, Reginald, without consulting him, and he wanted an archbishop who would serve the Crown loyally. Innocent's decision to quash de Gray's election as well as Reginald's left John without the man he wanted.

Third, John distrusted Langton personally. Although Langton was English, he had spent most of his career teaching theology in Paris, the capital of John's enemy Philip II. John claimed that Langton was a stranger to him and too closely tied to the French court. With Normandy lost in 1204 and John planning to win it back, he did not want the leading churchman in England to be a man he regarded as close to his enemies.

Finally, John's wider interests and his character made compromise less likely. Accepting Langton would have set a precedent that the Pope, not the king, controlled appointments to the greatest offices in the English Church. Kings remembered how much trouble an independent archbishop, Thomas Becket, had caused Henry II. While Canterbury was vacant, John also enjoyed its revenues. John was stubborn and quick to anger, and he seems to have believed that Innocent would back down.

John's refusal therefore came from a mixture of principle, politics and personal distrust: he saw the issue as a defence of royal rights, he wanted a loyal servant at Canterbury, and he would not accept a man he believed was close to France.

Explanation

Level 4 answers explain several of John's reasons, such as his customary rights over the appointment, his wish to have John de Gray and his distrust of Langton's links with Paris, and link them, for example by showing why the archbishop mattered so much to the king. Answers that narrate the election of 1205-07 without explaining John's motives stay in the lower levels.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO2: 6 marks. AO1: 6 marks.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): An analytical explanation is given which is directed consistently at the conceptual focus of the question, showing a line of reasoning that is coherent, sustained and logically structured. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is precisely selected to address the question directly, showing wide-ranging knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. [AO1] No access to Level 4 for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): An explanation is given, showing some analysis, which is mainly directed at the conceptual focus of the question. It shows a line of reasoning that is generally sustained, although some passages may lack coherence and organisation. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is included, showing good knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. [AO1] Maximum 8 marks for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): An explanation is given, showing limited analysis and with implicit or unsustained links to the conceptual focus of the question. It shows some development and organisation of material, but a line of reasoning is not sustained. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is included, showing some knowledge and understanding of the period. [AO1]
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): A simple or generalised answer is given, lacking development and organisation. [AO2] Limited knowledge and understanding of the topic is shown. [AO1]
    0 marks: No rewardable material.
    Performance in AO1 and AO2 is interdependent. An answer displaying no qualities of AO2 cannot be awarded more than the top of Level 1, no matter how strong performance is in AO1; markers should note that the expectation for AO1 is that candidates demonstrate both knowledge and understanding.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Royal rights and custom: Norman and Angevin kings had a decisive say in choosing bishops and archbishops; the archbishop was a tenant-in-chief with great estates and knights, crowned the king and was normally one of his chief advisers (Hubert Walter, who died on 13 July 1205, had been justiciar and then chancellor); Langton was elected by Canterbury monks in Rome in December 1206 in Innocent III's presence, and John complained that his consent had not properly been sought; Innocent consecrated Langton at Viterbo on 17 June 1207 regardless; John saw this as an attack on the customary rights of the Crown. John de Gray: Bishop of Norwich, a trusted royal servant and fundraiser; John made the monks elect him in December 1205 after some monks had secretly elected their subprior, Reginald, without the king's consent; Innocent quashed both elections (1206), so John lost the man he wanted. Distrust of Langton: although English (probably from Lincolnshire, with a prebend at York), Langton had spent his career teaching theology in Paris, the capital of John's enemy Philip II; John said he was a stranger to him and too close to the French court; after the loss of Normandy (1204) John wanted a reliable man at Canterbury. Precedent and power: giving way would let the Pope control the greatest appointments in the English Church; the memory of Thomas Becket's quarrel with Henry II; Church reformers had long challenged royal control of elections. Money: while Canterbury was vacant the king took its revenues. John's character: stubborn, suspicious and quick to anger; he may have expected Innocent to compromise. Answers that narrate the election without explaining John's reasons for refusing Langton should not go beyond Level 2. Do not credit the claims that Langton was French or a monk, or that John refused him because he supported the barons (his role with the barons came later).

    Pearson's marking instructions: The middle mark in each level may be achieved by stronger performance in either AO1 or AO2.

Question 3

12 marks

Explain why Pope Innocent III was willing to make peace with King John in 1213.

You may use the following in your answer:
- Stephen Langton
- the papal fief

You must also use information of your own.

Model answer

Innocent III was willing to make peace with John in 1213 because John gave him what he had been fighting for, because the settlement brought the papacy new power and prestige, and because the Pope had wider plans that needed peace in Christendom.

First, John accepted the Pope's main demands. He agreed to receive Stephen Langton as Archbishop of Canterbury, to allow the exiled bishops and the Canterbury monks to return, and to compensate the Church for what he had taken. This meant that Innocent had won the principle at the heart of the dispute: that the Church, guided by the Pope, could choose the Archbishop of Canterbury without the king's control. Church law also expected a pope to forgive a sinner who repented, and Innocent's aim had always been to make John submit, not to destroy him.

Second, John offered more than Innocent had asked. On 15 May 1213 he surrendered England and Ireland to the Pope and received them back as a fief, doing homage and promising a tribute of 1,000 marks a year. Having a powerful king as his vassal greatly increased the Pope's prestige, and it made John a dependent ally rather than an enemy.

Third, Innocent did not want Philip II of France to become too powerful. Philip had already conquered Normandy and Anjou, and if he had taken England as well he would have dominated western Europe. Innocent had his own quarrels with Philip, especially over Philip's treatment of his wife, Ingeborg. Once John had submitted, Pandulf ordered Philip to abandon his invasion.

Fourth, Innocent had wider plans. In 1213 he called a new crusade to recover Jerusalem and summoned a great council of the whole Church, which met in Rome in 1215. Both needed peace between Christian rulers and money from their kingdoms, and a long quarrel with England stood in the way.

Finally, the Interdict was harming the people of England. For five years ordinary Christians had been without Mass and Christian burial, and many churchmen were in exile. A pope who saw himself as the shepherd of all Christians had good reason to end this once the king gave way.

Innocent made peace because he had achieved his aims over Langton and gained lordship over England, and because a reconciled John was more useful to him than a defeated one, both as a check on France and for his plans for the crusade and the Church.

Explanation

Top-level answers explain the reconciliation from the Pope's point of view, for example his success over Langton, the prestige of the papal fief, his fear of an over-mighty France and his plans for a crusade. Answers that only explain why John submitted do not address the question.

Mark scheme
  1. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO2: 6 marks. AO1: 6 marks.
    Level 4 (10-12 marks): An analytical explanation is given which is directed consistently at the conceptual focus of the question, showing a line of reasoning that is coherent, sustained and logically structured. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is precisely selected to address the question directly, showing wide-ranging knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. [AO1] No access to Level 4 for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 3 (7-9 marks): An explanation is given, showing some analysis, which is mainly directed at the conceptual focus of the question. It shows a line of reasoning that is generally sustained, although some passages may lack coherence and organisation. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is included, showing good knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. [AO1] Maximum 8 marks for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 2 (4-6 marks): An explanation is given, showing limited analysis and with implicit or unsustained links to the conceptual focus of the question. It shows some development and organisation of material, but a line of reasoning is not sustained. [AO2] Accurate and relevant information is included, showing some knowledge and understanding of the period. [AO1]
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): A simple or generalised answer is given, lacking development and organisation. [AO2] Limited knowledge and understanding of the topic is shown. [AO1]
    0 marks: No rewardable material.
    Performance in AO1 and AO2 is interdependent. An answer displaying no qualities of AO2 cannot be awarded more than the top of Level 1, no matter how strong performance is in AO1; markers should note that the expectation for AO1 is that candidates demonstrate both knowledge and understanding.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Innocent's aims achieved: John accepted Langton, the return of the exiled bishops and the Canterbury monks, and compensation; the principle of free election to Canterbury was upheld; Church law expected a penitent sinner to be forgiven, and the purpose of the Interdict and excommunication was to bring John to submit, not to destroy him. The papal fief: on 15 May 1213 John surrendered England and Ireland and received them back as a fief, did homage and swore fealty, and promised 1,000 marks a year (700 for England, 300 for Ireland); this brought the papacy prestige and a powerful vassal, and turned John into a useful ally. The balance of power: Innocent did not want Philip II, who had already taken Normandy and Anjou, to conquer England as well; Innocent had his own quarrels with Philip (over his treatment of his wife, Ingeborg); Pandulf ordered Philip to abandon his invasion. Wider plans: in 1213 Innocent called a new crusade and summoned the Fourth Lateran Council (which met in Rome in 1215), so he needed peace among Christian rulers and money from their kingdoms. The suffering of England: five years without Mass and Christian burial, and clergy in exile; the Pope's role as shepherd of all Christians. Earlier negotiations (the papal envoys Pandulf and Durand met John at Northampton in 1211) show that Innocent had long been willing to settle on the right terms (credit). Answers that explain only why John submitted, without considering Innocent's reasons, should not go beyond Level 2. Do not credit the claim that Innocent gave up his support for Langton.

    Pearson's marking instructions: The middle mark in each level may be achieved by stronger performance in either AO1 or AO2.

Question 4

16 marks

'The money John took from the Church was the main reason why he was able to defy Pope Innocent III for so long in the years 1208-13.'

How far do you agree? Explain your answer.

You may use the following in your answer:
- vacant bishoprics
- hostages from the barons

You must also use information of your own.

Model answer

The Church's money was very important because it allowed John to govern and fight without taxing his subjects heavily, but he could only use it because he also kept control of his barons. I think his hold over the barons, backed by that money, was just as important.

There is a strong case for the statement. When the Interdict began in 1208, John seized the lands and revenues of clergy who obeyed it and of the bishops who fled. He kept many bishoprics and abbeys vacant and took their income, and in 1210 the Cistercian monks were forced to pay him a heavy levy. Estimates of his total gains range from about £67,000 to over £100,000. This wealth meant that he did not need a new general tax like that of 1207, so lay people and barons had less reason to turn against him. It also paid for mercenaries, a fleet, and campaigns in Scotland in 1209, Ireland in 1210 and Wales in 1211, and his success in them suggested that excommunication had not weakened him. The longer the dispute went on, the more money John received, so he had little reason to hurry.

However, other factors were also important. John kept firm control of his barons. Fearing that the Pope would release them from their loyalty, he demanded hostages from them in 1208. The fate of William de Braose, whose wife refused to hand over her son and whose family was then hunted down, showed what happened to those who defied him. In 1212, after the plot against him, he demanded hostages again and the plotters fled abroad.

The Pope's weapons were also weaker than they looked. The excommunication of November 1209 was not published in England because the bishops had fled, and the barons continued to serve John. Excommunication had lost some of its force because other rulers, such as Otto IV and Raymond VI of Toulouse, were also excommunicated. The Interdict allowed baptism and confession, and some of its rules were relaxed or quietly ignored, so popular anger was limited. Innocent moved slowly, and the threat of deposition and invasion only became real in 1212-13.

John also had loyal supporters in the Church, such as Peter des Roches and John de Gray, and his own stubborn character made him willing to endure excommunication.

Overall, I partly agree. If the criterion is what made resistance possible, the Church's money was the most important factor, because without it John would have had to tax his subjects heavily and risk revolt. But it was not enough on its own: the hostages and fear that kept the barons loyal, and the weakness of the Pope's weapons until 1212, explain why John could hold out until the threat of invasion finally forced him to submit.

Explanation

Level 4 answers explain the importance of the Church's money and then weigh it against other reasons for John's survival, such as his hold over the barons through hostages and the weakness of the Pope's sanctions until 1212, before reaching a judgement. Weaker answers describe the seizures without linking them to John's ability to hold out.

Mark scheme
  1. 16 marks

    Levels of response (16 marks).
    Level 4 (13-16 marks): An analytical explanation is given which is directed consistently at the conceptual focus of the question, showing a line of reasoning that is coherent, sustained and logically structured. Accurate and relevant information is precisely selected to address the question directly, showing wide-ranging knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. Criteria for the required judgement are justified and applied in the process of reaching the overall judgement. No access to Level 4 for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 3 (9-12 marks): An explanation is given, showing some analysis, which is mainly directed at the conceptual focus of the question. It shows a line of reasoning that is generally sustained, although some passages may lack coherence and organisation. Accurate and relevant information is included, showing good knowledge and understanding of the required features or characteristics of the period studied. The overall judgement is given with some justification, but some criteria selected for the required judgement are left implicit or not validly applied. Maximum 11 marks for answers that do not address three or more aspects of content.
    Level 2 (5-8 marks): An explanation is given showing limited analysis and with implicit or unsustained links to the conceptual focus of the question. It shows some development and organisation of material, but a line of reasoning is not sustained. Accurate and relevant information is included, showing some knowledge and understanding of the period. The overall judgement is given but its justification is asserted or insecure.
    Level 1 (1-4 marks): A simple or generalised answer is given, lacking development and organisation. Limited knowledge and understanding of the topic is shown. The overall judgement is missing or asserted.
    0 marks: No rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Points that support the statement: Church revenues (lands of clergy who obeyed the Interdict and of the exiled bishops; vacant bishoprics and abbeys kept in royal hands); the Cistercians' levy (1210); total gains estimated at between about £67,000 and over £100,000 (accept figures in this range); no need for a new general tax like that of 1207, so lay people had less reason to turn against him; money paid for mercenaries, the fleet, alliances (Otto IV) and successful campaigns in Scotland (1209), Ireland (1210) and Wales (1211); the longer the dispute lasted, the more John gained. Points that counter the statement: control of the barons: hostages demanded in 1208 (Wendover) and again in 1212; the fate of the de Braose family as a warning; the plotters of 1212 fled; the weakness of papal sanctions: the excommunication (November 1209) was not published in England, the barons kept serving him, and other rulers (Raymond VI, Otto IV) were also excommunicated; the Interdict allowed baptism and confession and was relaxed (1209, 1212) or quietly ignored in places, limiting popular anger; Innocent moved slowly, and the threats of deposition and invasion became serious only in 1212-13; loyal churchmen (Peter des Roches, John de Gray); John's stubborn character. A substantiated judgement might argue that the money made resistance possible while control of the barons and the weakness of papal sanctions made it safe, or that the money was the foundation of everything else. Do not credit events after May 1213 as reasons for John's resistance.

    Pearson's marking instructions (part of the mark scheme): AO2: 10 marks. AO1: 6 marks. In each level the first bullet point (the explanation and line of reasoning) is [AO2], the second (the information, knowledge and understanding) is [AO1] and the third (the overall judgement) is [AO2]. Performance in AO1 and AO2 is interdependent. An answer displaying no qualities of AO2 cannot be awarded more than the top of Level 1, no matter how strong performance is in AO1; markers should note that the expectation for AO1 is that candidates demonstrate both knowledge and understanding. The first two bullet points [AO1 and AO2] account for 3 of the 4 marks in the level and are equally weighted; the third bullet point [AO2] accounts for the remaining mark. Once the level has been found, there are two steps to follow to determine the mark within the level: Markers should consider bullet points 1 and 2 together. Strong performance (for the level) in both would be awarded all 3 marks, while 2 marks may be achieved by stronger performance in either bullet point; weak performance would be awarded 1 mark. The fourth mark in each level is allocated to the bullet point 3 and should be considered independently of the award of the other marks.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.