'Laws alone cannot end discrimination in the UK.'
Considering a range of views, to what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
In your answer you should consider:
- how laws such as the Equality Act 2010 deal with discrimination
- other ways that attitudes and behaviour can be changed.
Model answer
I largely agree that laws alone cannot end discrimination, although laws are an essential part of the answer.
On one side, laws such as the Equality Act 2010 have made a real difference. The Act brought together over 100 earlier laws and makes it unlawful to discriminate because of nine protected characteristics, including race, sex, disability and religion, at work, in education and in services. Victims can take a claim to an employment tribunal or a court and win compensation, which deters employers from discriminating. The Act also makes organisations act before anyone complains: public bodies must consider equality in their decisions, and employers must make reasonable adjustments for disabled people. Large employers now have to publish their gender pay gap figures, which puts public pressure on them. History suggests that laws can change attitudes as well as behaviour: race and sex discrimination were once open and accepted in Britain, but laws passed since the 1960s and 1970s helped to make them socially unacceptable.
On the other side, discrimination clearly still exists. More than fifty years after the Equal Pay Act 1970 there is still a gender pay gap, and racist abuse of footballers and others continues online. Laws mostly act after the event and depend on victims bringing a claim, which can be expensive and stressful, and discrimination is often hard to prove because it is hidden or unconscious. Laws also cannot reach people's private attitudes. That is why education matters so much: citizenship lessons, campaigns such as Show Racism the Red Card, positive role models and media representation, and community projects that bring different groups together can all change attitudes in a way that the threat of a tribunal cannot.
Weighing these points, laws are necessary because they set clear standards, give victims justice and force organisations to act, and without them campaigns would have little power. But because discrimination continues despite decades of legislation, the evidence shows that laws are not enough on their own. Discrimination will only be ended when strong laws are combined with education and changes in attitudes, so I agree with the statement.
Explanation
Top answers explain how the Equality Act 2010 works (protected characteristics, claims and compensation, reasonable adjustments, the public sector equality duty) and weigh this against evidence that discrimination continues, then assess other ways of changing attitudes. A clear judgement, such as 'laws are necessary but not sufficient', is needed for Level 4. One-sided answers are capped at 4.