'Ordinary citizens, not legal professionals, should decide the outcome of criminal cases.'
Considering a range of views, to what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
In your answer you should consider:
- the role of jurors
- the role of magistrates.
Model answer
Many people agree that ordinary citizens should decide criminal cases. Trial by jury is one of the oldest safeguards of liberty in England, often traced back to Magna Carta's promise of 'lawful judgment' by a person's peers. Jurors are chosen at random from the electoral register, so the verdict comes from people with a wide range of backgrounds rather than from the state. Because they are independent of the government, juries can protect citizens against unjust prosecutions, and they can even acquit a defendant if they think convicting would be unfair. Twelve people must reach a unanimous verdict, or a majority of at least 10-2, so no single person decides. Magistrates also show the value of citizens' involvement: they are unpaid volunteers from the local community who deal with the great majority of criminal cases. They sit in panels of usually three, are trained, and are advised on the law by a legal adviser, so they combine local knowledge with legal support at a far lower cost than professional judges. Involving citizens like this increases public confidence in the system.
However, there are serious arguments against the statement. Jurors have no legal training and may struggle to follow long and complex evidence, such as in fraud trials. They may be influenced by prejudice or by what they read in the media and on social media, and some have broken the rules by researching cases online. Because jury deliberations are secret and juries do not give reasons, it is very hard to know whether a verdict was reached properly or to appeal against it. Jury trials are also slow and expensive, adding to long delays in the Crown Court, which harm victims, witnesses and defendants waiting for justice. This has led to a bill, introduced in 2026, that proposes restricting jury trials in some cases, though critics argue this would weaken an important protection. Magistrates have tended to be older than the population as a whole and have not always reflected their communities, and sentences can vary between areas. Professional judges, including district judges, are trained, more consistent and give reasoned decisions that can be appealed.
Overall, I largely agree with the statement. The involvement of ordinary citizens as jurors and magistrates gives the justice system democratic legitimacy and protects people from the power of the state, which matters more than the extra speed professionals might bring. However, citizens work best with professional support, such as judges directing juries on the law and legal advisers helping magistrates, and there may be a case for professional judges in some very complex or lengthy cases.
Explanation
Top answers address both bullet points, weighing the democratic value, independence and public confidence that jurors and magistrates bring against concerns about expertise, bias, secrecy, consistency and delay, and reach a reasoned judgement. Do not state the proposed restrictions on jury trials as law: at the time of writing they were in a bill, not an Act.