'The Human Rights Act 1998 gives too much power to judges.'
Considering a range of views, to what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
In your answer you should consider:
- the role of the courts in protecting rights
- the sovereignty of Parliament.
Model answer
Some people believe the Human Rights Act 1998 gives too much power to judges. Judges are appointed rather than elected, and voters cannot remove them, yet the Act asks them to decide difficult moral and political questions, such as whether deporting a foreign criminal would breach the right to family life. Section 3 of the Act requires courts to read laws so that they fit Convention rights wherever possible, and critics argue that judges have sometimes stretched the meaning of Acts: in a 2004 case, the House of Lords read a housing law as including same-sex partners even though the wording referred to husbands and wives. UK courts must also take account of the European Court of Human Rights, which treats the Convention as a 'living instrument' that can extend rights over time. Concerns like these led some politicians to propose replacing the Act, for example in the Bill of Rights Bill of 2022, which was later dropped.
However, there are strong arguments that the Act was carefully designed to keep power with Parliament. Parliament passed the Act, and it can amend or repeal it whenever it chooses. Most importantly, UK judges cannot strike down Acts of Parliament. If a law cannot be read in a way that fits Convention rights, the most a higher court can do is make a declaration of incompatibility, and the law stays in force until Parliament decides what to do. For example, when the Supreme Court declared in 2018 that civil partnerships for same-sex couples only were incompatible, it was Parliament that changed the law in 2019. Section 3 also applies only 'so far as it is possible', so judges must follow clear words. This gives UK judges far less power than courts in some countries, such as the US Supreme Court, which can strike down laws. Independent judges are also needed to protect minorities and unpopular groups, whose rights might otherwise be ignored by a majority, and to hold public bodies to account, as in the new Hillsborough inquests, which ended in 2016 and, because of the right to life, looked more widely at the circumstances in which people died.
Overall, I disagree with the statement. The Act does give judges an important role in difficult and sometimes controversial cases, and critics are right that this can draw them into political questions. But because judges cannot overturn Acts of Parliament and Parliament keeps the power to change or repeal the Act, the final decision always rests with elected MPs. The Act gives judges enough power to protect rights without taking power away from Parliament.
Explanation
Top answers address both bullet points: how the courts protect rights under the Act (interpreting laws, declarations of incompatibility, holding public bodies to account) and how parliamentary sovereignty is preserved, weighing criticisms of unelected judges against these safeguards before reaching a judgement. A common error is to claim that judges can strike down or cancel laws under the Act, which is wrong.