'The age of criminal responsibility in England and Wales is too low.'
Considering a range of views, to what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
In your answer you should consider:
- when children become able to take responsibility for their actions
- how other parts of the UK and other countries deal with children who offend.
Model answer
I agree that the age of criminal responsibility in England and Wales is too low, although there are reasonable arguments for keeping it.
The case for raising it is strong. At 10, England and Wales have one of the lowest ages in Europe. Scotland raised its age to 12 in 2021, and countries such as Germany, Italy and Spain set it at 14, which is also the minimum the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child recommends. Research shows that the parts of the brain that control impulses and judgement keep developing well into the teenage years, so a 10-year-old may not fully understand the consequences of their actions. Many young children who offend have been abused, neglected or exploited by adults, for example by gangs using children to carry drugs, so they are victims as well as offenders and need help rather than punishment. A criminal record at such a young age can also damage a child's education and job prospects for years, making further offending more likely.
On the other hand, supporters of the current age argue that most 10-year-olds know the difference between right and wrong, and that the law must protect victims and the public, especially in the rare cases where young children commit very serious crimes. They also point out that a 10-year-old is not treated like an adult: youth courts, youth offending teams and orders such as referral orders focus on rehabilitation, and many young children are dealt with outside court through diversion schemes. Early intervention, they argue, can stop children's offending becoming more serious. Northern Ireland also uses 10, so the age is not unusual within the UK.
Weighing these views, the evidence about children's development, and the fact that Scotland and most of Europe have chosen higher ages without losing the ability to deal with serious harm, convinces me that 10 is too low. Scotland's Children's Hearings System shows that children who offend can still be held to account and supervised, but through a welfare approach that tackles the causes of their behaviour. So I agree with the statement, and think the age should rise to at least 12, with serious cases still dealt with through the welfare and protection system.
Explanation
Top answers use evidence about child development, comparisons with Scotland and other countries, and the purposes of youth justice, and weigh these against public protection and the welfare focus that already exists in youth courts. A clear judgement, supported by the evidence, is needed for Level 4. One-sided answers are capped at 4.