'Barriers to participation mean that only some groups in society really have their voices heard.'
Considering a range of views, to what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
In your answer you should consider:
- the opportunities citizens have to take part in democracy
- the barriers that stop some groups from taking part.
Model answer
I partly agree with this statement. There are real barriers that mean some groups are heard more than others, but I do not think only some groups are heard, because citizens have many opportunities to take part and the barriers can be overcome.
The case for agreeing is strong. Turnout is much lower among younger people and people on low incomes than among older and wealthier people, so politicians have a reason to focus on the groups who vote most. Practical barriers make this worse: people working long hours or caring for relatives have little time, some people lack internet access as more information moves online, and some disabled people and people with limited English find it harder to take part. Photo ID is now needed at polling stations in UK general elections and local elections in England, and some people without accepted ID have been turned away. Groups with money and contacts, such as large businesses, can also afford professional lobbyists, while ordinary citizens cannot. Because MPs and councillors do not fully reflect the population, some groups feel that politics is 'not for people like us', which deepens apathy.
However, there are more opportunities to participate than ever. As well as voting, citizens can contact their MP or councillor, sign and start petitions, use social media to campaign, answer council consultations, volunteer and join pressure groups. Postal and proxy votes help people who cannot get to a polling station. 16 and 17-year-olds can already vote in Scottish Parliament and Senedd elections, and a bill in Parliament would extend this to UK elections. Groups who find it hard to speak for themselves are supported by charities and trade unions that act as advocates, and ordinary people have changed policy, for example the 2020 campaign that persuaded the government to extend free school meal support into the holidays. Many people who do not take part choose not to, rather than being stopped.
Weighing these arguments, the barriers are serious for particular groups, especially young people, poorer people and disabled people, and they do make some voices louder than others. But the evidence that ordinary people's campaigns succeed shows that most citizens can be heard if they use the opportunities available. So the statement goes too far: the problem is unequal influence rather than most people being silenced, and it should be tackled through better citizenship education, accessible voting and outreach by councils and charities.
Explanation
This 8-mark question is marked by levels. Top answers analyse a wide range of evidence on both sides (who votes and who does not, practical barriers, voter ID, lobbying power, and the many ways to take part) and reach a supported judgement. An answer that only lists barriers is capped at 4; an answer that discusses both sides but never says how far it agrees is capped at 6.