'A shared British identity is becoming less important to people in the UK.'
Considering a range of views, to what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
In your answer you should consider:
• the four nations that make up the UK
• multiple identities in a diverse society.
Model answer
There is evidence that a shared British identity is becoming less important in some parts of the UK. Since devolution in 1999, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland have had their own parliaments or assemblies, which make decisions about health and education, so many people now look first to their own nation. In Scotland, 44.7% voted for independence in the 2014 referendum, and the debate has not gone away. In Northern Ireland, identity is divided: in the 2021 Census only about a third of people said they were 'British only', while nearly three in ten said 'Irish only' and about a fifth 'Northern Irish only', and the share who described themselves as British, alone or with another identity, fell from 48.4% in 2011 to 42.8%. The 2016 EU referendum also showed differences between the nations, as Scotland and Northern Ireland voted to remain while England and Wales voted to leave. Some young people also feel that local, religious or global identities matter more to them than any national one.
However, there is also strong evidence that British identity remains important. In the 2021 Census, 54.8% of people in England and Wales described themselves as 'British only', although the ONS says that the big rise from 19.1% in 2011 is most likely the result of a change to the form, which listed 'British' first in England in 2021. In 2014, a majority of 55.3% of Scottish voters chose to stay in the UK. Many people from minority ethnic groups describe themselves as British Asian or Black British, which shows that Britishness can be an umbrella identity that people from many backgrounds share. Because most people have multiple identities, being Welsh or Scottish does not stop someone also feeling British. Shared institutions such as the NHS and events such as Team GB at the Olympics still bring people together, and new citizens pledge loyalty to the UK.
Overall, I disagree with the statement to some extent. British identity is not disappearing, but it is changing: for many people it is now one layer among several identities rather than the main one. It is weaker in Northern Ireland and in parts of Scotland, but it remains strong in England, including among many minority ethnic groups. So it would be more accurate to say that a shared British identity is becoming more varied, and more important to some people than to others, rather than simply less important.
Explanation
A top answer uses evidence from more than one nation (devolution, referendums, Census results) and from the idea of multiple identities, argues both sides and reaches a judgement. Answers that only describe the four nations, or assert that people feel more Scottish or Welsh without evidence, stay in the lower levels. Strong answers notice that a national identity and a British identity can be held together, and that the picture differs between the nations.