'The rule of law is the most important of the fundamental British values.'
Considering a range of views, to what extent do you agree or disagree with this statement?
In your answer you should consider:
• how the rule of law protects citizens' rights and freedoms
• the other fundamental British values.
Model answer
Some people agree that the rule of law is the most important British value because the other values depend on it. The rule of law means that everyone, including the government, must obey the law and is treated equally by it. Without this, rights and freedoms would only be promises. For example, individual liberty is protected because independent courts can rule that the government has acted unlawfully, as the Supreme Court did in 2019 when it ruled that the government's advice to suspend Parliament was unlawful. The rule of law also protects tolerance: laws against stirring up racial or religious hatred protect minority groups. Even democracy depends on it, because elections must be run according to the law and the losers must accept the result. Some countries hold elections but ignore the law, which shows that voting alone is not enough.
However, others argue that democracy is more important. The rule of law only means that laws are applied equally, not that the laws are fair. A state can apply unjust laws strictly: for example, sex between men was once a crime in the UK, and it was democracy and campaigning that changed this, starting with the Sexual Offences Act 1967 in England and Wales. Democracy gives laws their legitimacy, because they are made by representatives whom citizens elect and can remove. Another view is that mutual respect and tolerance matter most in a diverse society: the law can punish hate crime, but it cannot make people respect each other, and community cohesion depends on how citizens treat one another every day. Some people would also say that individual liberty is the most important value, because protecting freedom is the purpose of the others.
A further view is that it is wrong to rank the values at all, because they depend on each other. The rule of law protects liberty, democracy makes the laws, and tolerance stops a majority using democracy to harm minorities.
Overall, I agree with the statement to a large extent, but not completely. The rule of law is the foundation that makes the other values enforceable, so without it they could not survive. But on its own it is not enough, because unfair laws can be applied equally to everyone. It is most important when it works together with democracy, which makes sure that the laws themselves are fair and can be changed.
Explanation
A top answer explains what the rule of law protects, weighs it against each of the other values (democracy, individual liberty, mutual respect and tolerance) with evidence, and reaches a reasoned judgement. Answers that only describe the four values, or argue one side, cannot go above Level 2. The strongest answers notice that the values depend on each other and that equal application of an unfair law is not justice.