A PE teacher is teaching a group of Year 7 beginners how to perform a lay-up in basketball.
Evaluate the use of visual guidance and verbal guidance for teaching this group.
Model answer
Visual guidance is guidance the performer sees, such as a demonstration, while verbal guidance is guidance they hear, such as an explanation. Visual guidance is very suitable for Year 7 beginners because they may never have seen a lay-up performed properly. If the teacher, or a skilled pupil, demonstrates it, the group can build a mental picture of the skill and copy it. The demonstration can be slowed down and broken into stages, such as the two steps and the jump, and the whole group can watch at once. However, the demonstration must be accurate, or pupils will copy mistakes, and if it is performed at full speed beginners may not see the key points.
Verbal guidance can highlight those key points with simple cue words, such as 'right, left, up' and 'aim for the top corner of the box', and the teacher can give it while the pupils practise. However, beginners can easily be overloaded if they are given too much information, technical terms may confuse them, and a noisy sports hall makes instructions hard to hear. On its own, verbal guidance does not give beginners a clear picture of the skill.
Overall, visual guidance is the more important for this group, but it works best when combined with short, simple verbal cues that focus the pupils' attention on the key points of the demonstration.
Explanation
Strong answers evaluate each type of guidance for this group - its strengths and its weaknesses for young beginners learning a lay-up - and reach a judgement, often that visual guidance should lead, supported by brief verbal cues. A common mistake is to describe the two types of guidance without linking them to beginners or to the lay-up.