Lily is a beginner learning to serve in volleyball.
Evaluate the use of different types of feedback for Lily.
Model answer
Feedback can be positive or negative, knowledge of results (KR) or knowledge of performance (KP), and intrinsic or extrinsic. As Lily is a beginner, positive feedback would be very effective. If her coach says 'Great - you hit the ball with the heel of your hand', it reinforces the correct action and builds her confidence and motivation. Negative feedback should be used carefully, because a beginner makes many errors and constant criticism could demotivate her; it should be constructive and combined with praise.
KR, such as whether the serve landed in the court, is simple and easy for Lily to understand, and it motivates her when the serve goes in. However, it does not tell her why a serve went into the net, so she would also benefit from simple KP, such as 'toss the ball a little lower', which helps her correct her technique. The KP must be brief, as too much detail could overload her.
Extrinsic feedback from her coach is essential, because Lily does not yet know what a good serve feels like, so she cannot rely on intrinsic feedback. As she practises, she will start to recognise the feel of a good contact, and intrinsic feedback will become more useful.
Overall, Lily would benefit most from positive, extrinsic feedback, using KR together with simple KP, with negative feedback kept constructive and limited.
Explanation
Strong answers cover all three pairs of feedback types, apply each to Lily's serve and judge how useful each one is for a beginner, ending with a clear conclusion. A common mistake is to define the types of feedback without evaluating them for a beginner.