Level:
Correct: 0
Incorrect: 0
Marks: 0/0
Exam Practice
Course:
Topics:
Avg
score:
–
Topics
done:
0/14

Writing a story with a given title

Practise 16 exam-style questions on Writing a story with a given title for Edexcel International GCSE English Language A (Paper 2). Write your answer as you would in the exam and get it marked in seconds against the mark scheme, point by point, with the Study Helper on hand if you get stuck.

  • 16 questions
  • 30 marks each
  • Instant marking
  • No sign-up needed
16 questions, marked as you go

Sample questions with model answers

Here are 4 of the questions in this topic, each with a model answer, an explanation of why it earns the marks and the mark scheme an examiner would use.

Question 1

30 marks

Write a story with the title 'Footprints in the Sand'.

Your response could be real or imagined.

Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.

Model answer

The tide had gone out in the night and left the beach as smooth as a freshly made bed, which was why Eilidh noticed the footprints at once.

They came out of the sea.

She stopped so suddenly that Tam, her old collie, ran into the back of her legs. It was half past six on an April morning, the sky a pale, rinsed grey, and nobody - nobody - walked on this beach but her. The nearest house apart from her own was two miles away. And yet there they were: the prints of two bare feet, beginning at the lip of the water and leading up across the wet sand towards the dunes.

There were no prints going back.

Eilidh looked out to sea. The Atlantic stretched away empty to the horizon, heaving and grey, flecked with white. No boat. No swimmer. Only a single gull, hanging motionless in the wind.

Tam whined and pulled towards the prints, nose to the ground.

She followed them. Up close they were strange. The spacing was wrong: long, then short, then wandering sideways. In one place they stopped, and there were two deep hollows side by side - knees - and the print of a spread hand, fingers clawed into the sand. Then they went on, dragging now, the toes scraping long furrows, towards the old stone boat shed at the foot of the dunes.

Her mouth had gone dry. She thought about going home to fetch her father. She thought about the water, which in April was so cold that it made her ankles ache in seconds.

She ran.

The door of the boat shed hung open on one hinge. Inside it was dim and smelled of tar and rotting rope, and in the corner, curled against a pile of old nets, was a young man in a torn black wetsuit. His lips were blue. His whole body was shaking in long, violent shudders, and when he saw her his eyes struggled to focus.

'Kayak,' he whispered. 'Went over. Swam.' His teeth chattered so hard she could barely understand him. 'Didn't think... anyone...'

Eilidh's hands were trembling too, but they knew what to do. She pulled off her thick jacket and wrapped it round him. She called 999 and asked for the Coastguard, and made herself speak slowly: the name of the beach, the boat shed, the blue lips, the shaking. She kept him talking - his name was Callum, he was from Glasgow, he had been paddling round the headland when the wind changed - and she pressed Tam against his side, and Tam, who understood more than most people, lay down against him and did not move.

Twenty-three minutes later she heard the helicopter: a deep, beating thunder rolling in over the sea, growing until the whole shed shook and the sand outside rose in stinging clouds.

Afterwards, when it was over, she walked back along the beach alone. The tide had turned. The water was creeping up the sand, and already the footprints were softening at their edges, filling, fading, the sea taking back what it had given.

By the afternoon there would be nothing left of them at all. But Eilidh knew that for the rest of her life, every time she saw footprints in the sand, she would follow them to see where they went.

Explanation

The footprints drive the whole story: they create the opening mystery, supply clues (the knees, the clawed hand) that build suspense, and return at the end as the tide erases them, giving the title new meaning. Pace is controlled through one-line paragraphs ('They came out of the sea.', 'She ran.') and the rescue is credible and calm rather than melodramatic. Weaker responses mention footprints and then wander into an unrelated plot, use horror cliches, or solve the mystery in a sentence with no tension.

Mark scheme
  1. 18 marks

    Levels of response (18 marks). AO4 (communication and organisation).
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Communication is basic and limited in clarity; little awareness of the purpose of the writing or of the intended reader; little awareness of form, tone and register; ideas are few, thin or disconnected.
    Level 2 (4-7 marks): Communicates in a broadly appropriate way; some grasp of the purpose and of what the intended reader expects; straightforward use of form, tone and register; a simple sequence of events or details with some development.
    Level 3 (8-11 marks): Communicates clearly; a clear sense of purpose and of the reader's expectations; appropriate use of form, tone and register; ideas are developed and organised, with some deliberate choices of language and structure.
    Level 4 (12-15 marks): Communicates successfully; a secure realisation of the task that suits its purpose and meets the reader's expectations; effective use of form, tone and register; well-chosen detail and a crafted, engaging structure.
    Level 5 (16-18 marks): Communication is perceptive and subtle; the task is sharply focused on its purpose and on the reader's expectations; sophisticated use of form, tone and register; an original, compelling and consistently controlled piece in which language and structure are shaped precisely for effect.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to write a real or imagined story with the title 'Footprints in the Sand', engaging the reader through mystery, tension or reflection. Approaches may include narrative, description, anecdote, dialogue, reflection and literary techniques. Audience: a general readership; candidates may choose to write for adults or for young people. Form: a story (narrative), which may include description, dialogue or a monologue, with clear organisation: an engaging opening, development and a deliberate ending. The title need not be quoted in the text, but the story must clearly relate to it; it may be interpreted literally or figuratively. Responses may: use footprints as a mystery to be followed, a trace of the past or a symbol of a journey or of someone gone; create atmosphere through a beach, desert or dune setting described precisely; build suspense through clues, pace and the character's reactions; bring the story to a clear climax and resolution; return to the footprints at the end to give the story shape; use a voice that makes the piece interesting and believable for the chosen reader; use a register suited to the chosen form, which may include colloquial elements, dialogue within narrative or description, or a sustained single voice in a monologue. Higher-level responses: make the footprints drive both plot and meaning, control suspense through carefully released clues and short, tense paragraphs, and end with an image that gives the title fresh significance. Lower-level responses: mention footprints briefly before moving to a different story, rely on stock horror or mystery cliches, or resolve the mystery with no build-up. Mark by best fit: a response need not meet every descriptor of a level to be placed in it. A very brief or unfinished response gives limited evidence of a secure realisation of the task.

  2. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO5 (technical accuracy).
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Expresses ideas with limited use of structural and grammatical features; basic vocabulary, often misspelt; punctuation with basic control; undeveloped, often repetitive sentence structures.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Expresses and orders ideas, using paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features; some correctly spelt vocabulary (e.g. words with regular patterns); punctuation with some control; a range of sentence structures including coordination and subordination.
    Level 3 (5-7 marks): Develops and connects ideas, with paragraphing and grammatical features that make the meaning clear; varied vocabulary, with words containing irregular patterns spelt correctly; accurate and varied punctuation; sentence structures adapted as appropriate.
    Level 4 (8-10 marks): Manages ideas, using structural and grammatical features cohesively and deliberately across the text; wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors; a range of punctuation positioned for clarity; sentence structures managed for deliberate effect.
    Level 5 (11-12 marks): Manipulates complex ideas, using a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion; extensive vocabulary used strategically, with rare spelling errors that do not detract from meaning; accurate punctuation used for emphasis and precision; a range of sentence structures used accurately and selectively for particular effects.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Mark this point for technical accuracy only, by best fit, across the whole response: the range, precision and spelling of vocabulary (including ambitious and irregular words); the variety and control of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex, with short or minor sentences used deliberately for effect); paragraphing and cohesion (clear shifts of time, place, focus or speaker, and linking between paragraphs); and the accuracy and range of punctuation (sentence boundaries, commas in complex sentences, apostrophes, the punctuation of speech, and semicolons, colons, dashes and brackets used correctly). Frequent comma splices, run-on sentences, missing paragraphs or uncontrolled tense shifts keep a response in Level 2 or Level 3 however ambitious its vocabulary; Level 5 needs accuracy and deliberate, selective control throughout, though rare slips do not prevent it. A very brief response offers limited evidence of range.

Question 2

30 marks

Write a story with the title 'The Unopened Letter'.

Your response could be real or imagined.

Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.

Model answer

We found it at the bottom of a biscuit tin, under a bundle of old electricity bills, on the day we packed up my grandmother's house in San Fernando.

The envelope was pale blue and soft with age, the kind with red and blue stripes round the edge for airmail. It was addressed, in tall, slanting handwriting, to Miss Lena Ramdeen. The stamp showed a young Queen Elizabeth, and the postmark, smudged but still readable, said London, 1966.

It had never been opened.

'Nani,' I said, holding it up. 'Who's this from?'

My grandmother was sitting by the window, wrapping china in newspaper. She looked up, and for a moment her hands went completely still. Then she put down the cup she was holding very carefully, as though it had suddenly become much more fragile.

'Bring it here, Anika.'

I sat on the floor beside her chair. Outside, the afternoon heat pressed against the glass, and a kiskadee shrieked its name over and over from the mango tree. Nani turned the envelope in her fingers, but she did not open it.

'There was a boy,' she said at last. 'Before your grandfather. He went to London to study, and he wanted me to follow him. My father said no. Absolutely not. A young woman, alone, across the ocean?' She smiled faintly. 'So he went, and I stayed. And six months later this came.'

'And you never opened it? In sixty years?'

'I knew what it would say.' She traced the slanting letters with one fingertip. 'He would ask me again. He would tell me he had found a room, a job, a way. And if I read it, Anika, I would have gone. I know I would. I would have packed a bag that night.'

'So why didn't you?'

She was quiet for so long that I thought she would not answer. The kiskadee had stopped. Somewhere down the street a radio was playing calypso, faint and tinny.

'Because I had met your grandfather by then,' she said simply. 'At a wedding. He trod on my foot while we were dancing and apologised so many times that I had to laugh. Fifty-four years, we had. Four children. This house.' She looked round the half-packed room: the pale squares on the walls where the photographs had been, the boxes, the bare shelves. 'A good life. A full one.'

'Don't you ever wonder?'

'Every day for a while. Then every year. Now...' She shrugged. 'Now, sometimes.'

She held the letter out to me.

'Take it,' she said. 'Don't open it. Keep it. One day you will have a choice to make, and someone will tell you that you must decide this way or that. When that day comes, look at this and remember that there is always more than one good life waiting for you. You just have to choose one.'

I took it. It weighed almost nothing.

It is in my desk drawer now, still sealed, the pale blue fading a little more each year. Sometimes I hold it up to the light, and I can see the faint, folded shadow of the pages inside, and the dark lines of words I will never read.

I have never been tempted to open it. Not once.

Well. Almost never.

Explanation

This story turns the letter into a symbol of choice, revealing the backstory gradually through dialogue and pauses rather than in one block, and keeps the contents a mystery on purpose - an ambiguous ending that is clearly deliberate and invites reflection. Details of place (the kiskadee, the mango tree, calypso on a radio) are woven in lightly, and the final one-line paragraph adds a human, slightly humorous note. Weaker responses reveal everything too early, read the letter aloud with little build-up, or leave the ending vague by accident rather than by design.

Mark scheme
  1. 18 marks

    Levels of response (18 marks). AO4 (communication and organisation).
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Communication is basic and limited in clarity; little awareness of the purpose of the writing or of the intended reader; little awareness of form, tone and register; ideas are few, thin or disconnected.
    Level 2 (4-7 marks): Communicates in a broadly appropriate way; some grasp of the purpose and of what the intended reader expects; straightforward use of form, tone and register; a simple sequence of events or details with some development.
    Level 3 (8-11 marks): Communicates clearly; a clear sense of purpose and of the reader's expectations; appropriate use of form, tone and register; ideas are developed and organised, with some deliberate choices of language and structure.
    Level 4 (12-15 marks): Communicates successfully; a secure realisation of the task that suits its purpose and meets the reader's expectations; effective use of form, tone and register; well-chosen detail and a crafted, engaging structure.
    Level 5 (16-18 marks): Communication is perceptive and subtle; the task is sharply focused on its purpose and on the reader's expectations; sophisticated use of form, tone and register; an original, compelling and consistently controlled piece in which language and structure are shaped precisely for effect.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to write a real or imagined story with the title 'The Unopened Letter', engaging the reader through mystery, character and emotion. Approaches may include narrative, description, anecdote, dialogue, reflection and literary techniques. Audience: a general readership; candidates may choose to write for adults or for young people. Form: a story (narrative), which may include description, dialogue or a monologue, with clear organisation: an engaging opening, development and a deliberate ending. The title need not be quoted in the text, but the story must clearly relate to it; it may be interpreted literally or figuratively. Responses may: create intrigue around the letter: who wrote it, when, why it was never opened; develop the people connected to the letter, perhaps across generations; use dialogue to reveal backstory gradually; build to a decision about whether to open it; end in a way that keeps or resolves the mystery deliberately; use a voice that makes the piece interesting and believable for the chosen reader; use a register suited to the chosen form, which may include colloquial elements, dialogue within narrative or description, or a sustained single voice in a monologue. Higher-level responses: use the letter as a symbol (of choice, the past or a road not taken), reveal backstory with restraint, and choose an ending, possibly ambiguous, that is clearly deliberate and thought-provoking. Lower-level responses: explain everything at once, simply reveal the contents with little build-up, or make the letter incidental to the story. Mark by best fit: a response need not meet every descriptor of a level to be placed in it. A very brief or unfinished response gives limited evidence of a secure realisation of the task.

  2. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO5 (technical accuracy).
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Expresses ideas with limited use of structural and grammatical features; basic vocabulary, often misspelt; punctuation with basic control; undeveloped, often repetitive sentence structures.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Expresses and orders ideas, using paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features; some correctly spelt vocabulary (e.g. words with regular patterns); punctuation with some control; a range of sentence structures including coordination and subordination.
    Level 3 (5-7 marks): Develops and connects ideas, with paragraphing and grammatical features that make the meaning clear; varied vocabulary, with words containing irregular patterns spelt correctly; accurate and varied punctuation; sentence structures adapted as appropriate.
    Level 4 (8-10 marks): Manages ideas, using structural and grammatical features cohesively and deliberately across the text; wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors; a range of punctuation positioned for clarity; sentence structures managed for deliberate effect.
    Level 5 (11-12 marks): Manipulates complex ideas, using a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion; extensive vocabulary used strategically, with rare spelling errors that do not detract from meaning; accurate punctuation used for emphasis and precision; a range of sentence structures used accurately and selectively for particular effects.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Mark this point for technical accuracy only, by best fit, across the whole response: the range, precision and spelling of vocabulary (including ambitious and irregular words); the variety and control of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex, with short or minor sentences used deliberately for effect); paragraphing and cohesion (clear shifts of time, place, focus or speaker, and linking between paragraphs); and the accuracy and range of punctuation (sentence boundaries, commas in complex sentences, apostrophes, the punctuation of speech, and semicolons, colons, dashes and brackets used correctly). Frequent comma splices, run-on sentences, missing paragraphs or uncontrolled tense shifts keep a response in Level 2 or Level 3 however ambitious its vocabulary; Level 5 needs accuracy and deliberate, selective control throughout, though rare slips do not prevent it. A very brief response offers limited evidence of range.

Question 3

30 marks

Write a story with the title 'Breaking the Silence'.

Your response could be real or imagined.

Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.

Model answer

My father and my uncle had not spoken for twelve years, although their houses stood on opposite banks of the same narrow canal, close enough for each of them to hear the other's radio.

Nobody would tell me exactly what had happened. Something about my grandfather's paddy fields, sold or not sold; something said at a funeral that could not be unsaid. I only knew the shape of the silence. When my uncle's boat passed our steps, my father went indoors. When we met at the temple, the two of them stood at opposite ends of the crowd, like magnets turned the wrong way.

And every August, when our village's snake boat raced on the great lake, my uncle steered it, and my father did not go.

That year I was rowing for the first time. Our boat was over a hundred feet long, slender and black, its stern rising behind like the raised hood of a cobra. More than a hundred of us sat in pairs along its length, and at the stern stood the helmsmen with their long steering oars. My uncle was the chief helmsman. He had been since before I was born.

Two days before the race, the second helmsman went down with fever.

'There is nobody,' my uncle said at the practice, staring at the water. 'Nobody who knows how.'

But there was. Everyone in the village knew who had steered beside my uncle for ten years when they were young men, two brothers so perfectly matched that people said they shared one pair of arms.

That night I sat on our steps with my father, our feet in the warm canal, and asked him.

He said no. Then he said nothing at all for a long time, watching the lights on the far bank.

On the morning of the race, he was standing at the stern of our boat.

The lake was a heaving mass of colour: thousands of people packed along the banks, umbrellas, flags, drums, the boats lined up like great dark spears. My father and my uncle stood side by side at the stern, gripping their oars, looking straight ahead. They did not look at each other once.

The gun cracked.

We dug our oars into the water, a hundred blades striking as one, and the singers began the old rowing song, faster and faster, and the boat leapt forward as if it had been fired. Spray flew. My arms burned. The banks blurred into a roaring wall of noise. Beside us a rival boat edged ahead, then fell back, then surged again, the two prows locked together, neck and neck, and I could not breathe for the effort and the din.

Then, in the final stretch, our boat began to drift wide.

And over everything - the drums, the crowd, the song - I heard my uncle's voice, hoarse and urgent.

'Rajan! Left! Now!'

My father's oar bit into the water. The boat swung straight as an arrow. We crossed the line half a length ahead.

I do not remember much of what happened next. I remember shouting until my voice cracked. I remember the crowd pouring down the banks. But mostly I remember looking back along the boat and seeing my father and my uncle at the stern, their oars still in their hands, laughing and gripping each other's shoulders like two young men, saying the same things over and over as though twelve years of words were spilling out at once.

Explanation

This story makes the silence significant by showing its 'shape' through detail (the radios across the canal, the brothers like 'magnets turned the wrong way') and then uses a vivid event, the boat race, to force the brothers together convincingly. The silence breaks with a single urgent shout in the climax, which is understated but powerful, and the final image shows the change without explaining it. Weaker responses state that two people stopped and then started talking, with no build-up, or settle a long quarrel with one easy apology.

Mark scheme
  1. 18 marks

    Levels of response (18 marks). AO4 (communication and organisation).
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Communication is basic and limited in clarity; little awareness of the purpose of the writing or of the intended reader; little awareness of form, tone and register; ideas are few, thin or disconnected.
    Level 2 (4-7 marks): Communicates in a broadly appropriate way; some grasp of the purpose and of what the intended reader expects; straightforward use of form, tone and register; a simple sequence of events or details with some development.
    Level 3 (8-11 marks): Communicates clearly; a clear sense of purpose and of the reader's expectations; appropriate use of form, tone and register; ideas are developed and organised, with some deliberate choices of language and structure.
    Level 4 (12-15 marks): Communicates successfully; a secure realisation of the task that suits its purpose and meets the reader's expectations; effective use of form, tone and register; well-chosen detail and a crafted, engaging structure.
    Level 5 (16-18 marks): Communication is perceptive and subtle; the task is sharply focused on its purpose and on the reader's expectations; sophisticated use of form, tone and register; an original, compelling and consistently controlled piece in which language and structure are shaped precisely for effect.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to write a real or imagined story with the title 'Breaking the Silence', engaging the reader through character, conflict and resolution. Approaches may include narrative, description, anecdote, dialogue, reflection and literary techniques. Audience: a general readership; candidates may choose to write for adults or for young people. Form: a story (narrative), which may include description, dialogue or a monologue, with clear organisation: an engaging opening, development and a deliberate ending. The title need not be quoted in the text, but the story must clearly relate to it; it may be interpreted literally or figuratively. Responses may: interpret the title literally (a vow of silence, a quiet place, a sound in the night) or figuratively (ending a long estrangement, speaking out, sharing a secret); establish why the silence exists and what keeping it costs; build towards a moment when the silence is broken; use a setting or event that forces characters together; end with a clear sense of change; use a voice that makes the piece interesting and believable for the chosen reader; use a register suited to the chosen form, which may include colloquial elements, dialogue within narrative or description, or a sustained single voice in a monologue. Higher-level responses: make the silence and its breaking emotionally significant, use a vivid setting or event to bring the characters together convincingly, and make the moment the silence breaks understated and powerful. Lower-level responses: state that people were not speaking and then were, with little build-up, or resolve a long conflict too easily. Mark by best fit: a response need not meet every descriptor of a level to be placed in it. A very brief or unfinished response gives limited evidence of a secure realisation of the task.

  2. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO5 (technical accuracy).
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Expresses ideas with limited use of structural and grammatical features; basic vocabulary, often misspelt; punctuation with basic control; undeveloped, often repetitive sentence structures.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Expresses and orders ideas, using paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features; some correctly spelt vocabulary (e.g. words with regular patterns); punctuation with some control; a range of sentence structures including coordination and subordination.
    Level 3 (5-7 marks): Develops and connects ideas, with paragraphing and grammatical features that make the meaning clear; varied vocabulary, with words containing irregular patterns spelt correctly; accurate and varied punctuation; sentence structures adapted as appropriate.
    Level 4 (8-10 marks): Manages ideas, using structural and grammatical features cohesively and deliberately across the text; wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors; a range of punctuation positioned for clarity; sentence structures managed for deliberate effect.
    Level 5 (11-12 marks): Manipulates complex ideas, using a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion; extensive vocabulary used strategically, with rare spelling errors that do not detract from meaning; accurate punctuation used for emphasis and precision; a range of sentence structures used accurately and selectively for particular effects.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Mark this point for technical accuracy only, by best fit, across the whole response: the range, precision and spelling of vocabulary (including ambitious and irregular words); the variety and control of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex, with short or minor sentences used deliberately for effect); paragraphing and cohesion (clear shifts of time, place, focus or speaker, and linking between paragraphs); and the accuracy and range of punctuation (sentence boundaries, commas in complex sentences, apostrophes, the punctuation of speech, and semicolons, colons, dashes and brackets used correctly). Frequent comma splices, run-on sentences, missing paragraphs or uncontrolled tense shifts keep a response in Level 2 or Level 3 however ambitious its vocabulary; Level 5 needs accuracy and deliberate, selective control throughout, though rare slips do not prevent it. A very brief response offers limited evidence of range.

Question 4

30 marks

Write a story with the title 'The Storm'.

Your response could be real or imagined.

Your response will be marked for the accurate and appropriate use of vocabulary, spelling, punctuation and grammar.

Model answer

The storm had been building over Lisbon all afternoon, and so had my father.

I could feel both of them in the air: a heavy, pressing stillness, the sky over the river turning the yellow-grey of an old bruise, the swallows flying low and frantic between the rooftops. In our flat on the fourth floor, the windows were open to catch a breeze that never came. My father sat at the kitchen table with his newspaper, not reading it. I sat opposite, with the letter I had written to my piano teacher, not sending it.

'Eight years,' he said finally, without looking up. 'Eight years of lessons, Sofia.'

'I know.'

'Top marks at the conservatoire. Every year.'

'I know, Pai.'

'And now you want to throw it away. For what?' He put down the paper. 'For nothing.'

The first thunder came then, a long, low growl from somewhere over the river, so deep that I felt it in the table under my hands. Neither of us looked up.

I had tried to explain. I had tried for weeks. That I did not hate the piano, but I hated the practising; that every evening of scales felt like a door closing on something else; that what I loved was drawing, and that I wanted my evenings for that. But every time I began, I heard how it must sound to him - lazy, ungrateful, a waste - and the words dried up.

'It isn't nothing,' I said. 'It's my life.'

'Your life!' He laughed, but it was not a laugh. 'You are fifteen. You do not know what a waste is.'

Lightning split the sky outside, white and sudden, and for an instant every object in the kitchen stood out sharp and colourless. Then the rain came - not gradually but all at once, a roaring wall of water hammering the roof tiles and bouncing waist-high off the balcony. The lights flickered, buzzed and went out.

In the darkness, I heard my father sigh.

He did not move to find the candles. He sat there, a dark shape against the streaming window, and when he spoke again his voice was different: quieter, almost tired.

'I played the guitar,' he said. 'Did you know that? When I was your age. I was good. Very good.' The rain drummed. 'My father said it was a waste of time. That I should study something useful. So I stopped.' A pause. 'I have not touched a guitar in thirty years.'

I did not know. Nobody had ever told me.

'I did not want that for you,' he said. 'I wanted you to keep going. I wanted you to have the thing I gave up.' He gave a small, broken laugh. 'And instead I have turned into him.'

I reached across the table in the dark and found his hand. It was rough and warm and trembling slightly.

We sat like that while the storm passed over: the thunder rolling away east across the river, the roar of the rain softening to a patter, then a drip, then silence. When the lights came back on, we both blinked at each other as though we had just woken up.

The next week, I posted the letter to my piano teacher. And on the shelf in the hall, where his newspapers used to be, my father put a second-hand guitar, which I hear him playing late at night, badly, beautifully, when he thinks I am asleep.

Explanation

This story interweaves a literal storm with a family argument: the weather builds, breaks and passes in step with the conflict, but the pathetic fallacy is subtle rather than mechanical, and the power cut creates the darkness in which the father finally speaks honestly. The resolution is believable because it comes from a revelation about his past, and the final image of the guitar shows change without explanation. Weaker responses describe weather at length with little story, use cliches such as 'a dark and stormy night', or end the conflict with a sudden apology.

Mark scheme
  1. 18 marks

    Levels of response (18 marks). AO4 (communication and organisation).
    Level 1 (1-3 marks): Communication is basic and limited in clarity; little awareness of the purpose of the writing or of the intended reader; little awareness of form, tone and register; ideas are few, thin or disconnected.
    Level 2 (4-7 marks): Communicates in a broadly appropriate way; some grasp of the purpose and of what the intended reader expects; straightforward use of form, tone and register; a simple sequence of events or details with some development.
    Level 3 (8-11 marks): Communicates clearly; a clear sense of purpose and of the reader's expectations; appropriate use of form, tone and register; ideas are developed and organised, with some deliberate choices of language and structure.
    Level 4 (12-15 marks): Communicates successfully; a secure realisation of the task that suits its purpose and meets the reader's expectations; effective use of form, tone and register; well-chosen detail and a crafted, engaging structure.
    Level 5 (16-18 marks): Communication is perceptive and subtle; the task is sharply focused on its purpose and on the reader's expectations; sophisticated use of form, tone and register; an original, compelling and consistently controlled piece in which language and structure are shaped precisely for effect.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Purpose: to write a real or imagined story with the title 'The Storm', engaging the reader through atmosphere, conflict and resolution. Approaches may include narrative, description, anecdote, dialogue, reflection and literary techniques. Audience: a general readership; candidates may choose to write for adults or for young people. Form: a story (narrative), which may include description, dialogue or a monologue, with clear organisation: an engaging opening, development and a deliberate ending. The title need not be quoted in the text, but the story must clearly relate to it; it may be interpreted literally or figuratively. Responses may: present a literal storm, a figurative one (an argument, a crisis) or both working together; use weather to mirror characters' emotions (pathetic fallacy); build tension towards a climax and then release it; develop characters and conflict through dialogue; end with calm, change or reconciliation as the storm passes; use a voice that makes the piece interesting and believable for the chosen reader; use a register suited to the chosen form, which may include colloquial elements, dialogue within narrative or description, or a sustained single voice in a monologue. Higher-level responses: interweave a literal and a figurative storm with control, use pathetic fallacy subtly rather than mechanically, and resolve the conflict through a revealing, believable moment. Lower-level responses: describe weather at length with little story, rely on cliches ('it was a dark and stormy night'), or resolve conflict abruptly. Mark by best fit: a response need not meet every descriptor of a level to be placed in it. A very brief or unfinished response gives limited evidence of a secure realisation of the task.

  2. 12 marks

    Levels of response (12 marks). AO5 (technical accuracy).
    Level 1 (1-2 marks): Expresses ideas with limited use of structural and grammatical features; basic vocabulary, often misspelt; punctuation with basic control; undeveloped, often repetitive sentence structures.
    Level 2 (3-4 marks): Expresses and orders ideas, using paragraphs and a range of structural and grammatical features; some correctly spelt vocabulary (e.g. words with regular patterns); punctuation with some control; a range of sentence structures including coordination and subordination.
    Level 3 (5-7 marks): Develops and connects ideas, with paragraphing and grammatical features that make the meaning clear; varied vocabulary, with words containing irregular patterns spelt correctly; accurate and varied punctuation; sentence structures adapted as appropriate.
    Level 4 (8-10 marks): Manages ideas, using structural and grammatical features cohesively and deliberately across the text; wide, selective vocabulary with only occasional spelling errors; a range of punctuation positioned for clarity; sentence structures managed for deliberate effect.
    Level 5 (11-12 marks): Manipulates complex ideas, using a range of structural and grammatical features to support coherence and cohesion; extensive vocabulary used strategically, with rare spelling errors that do not detract from meaning; accurate punctuation used for emphasis and precision; a range of sentence structures used accurately and selectively for particular effects.
    0 marks: no rewardable material.

    Mark this point for technical accuracy only, by best fit, across the whole response: the range, precision and spelling of vocabulary (including ambitious and irregular words); the variety and control of sentence structures (simple, compound and complex, with short or minor sentences used deliberately for effect); paragraphing and cohesion (clear shifts of time, place, focus or speaker, and linking between paragraphs); and the accuracy and range of punctuation (sentence boundaries, commas in complex sentences, apostrophes, the punctuation of speech, and semicolons, colons, dashes and brackets used correctly). Frequent comma splices, run-on sentences, missing paragraphs or uncontrolled tense shifts keep a response in Level 2 or Level 3 however ambitious its vocabulary; Level 5 needs accuracy and deliberate, selective control throughout, though rare slips do not prevent it. A very brief response offers limited evidence of range.

Ready to try the rest? Every answer you write is marked against the mark scheme, so you can see exactly where the marks are.

Study Helper Hints first, answers after you try

Stuck on this one? Ask for a hint and I’ll point you in the right direction, without giving the answer away. Once you’ve checked your answer, I’ll show you how the marks are awarded.