Question 1
30 marksRemind yourself of 'Out, Out-' by Robert Frost in the Pearson Edexcel International GCSE English Anthology.
How does the poet present the buzz saw in 'Out, Out-'?
In your answer, you should write about:
- the way the saw is described at the start of the poem
- the part the saw plays in the accident
- the use of language and structure.
You should refer closely to the text to support your answer. You may include brief quotations.
Model answer
Frost presents the buzz saw as the most active and threatening presence in the poem. Through personification he makes it seem like a living, predatory creature, and its sound dominates the poem until it suddenly takes the boy's hand.
The poem begins with the saw: 'The buzz saw snarled and rattled'. Opening with the saw makes it the subject of the first sentence, the first thing the reader hears. The verb 'snarled' is animal-like, suggesting a dog baring its teeth, while 'rattled' suggests a harsh, mechanical noise and perhaps a rattlesnake's warning. The onomatopoeic name 'buzz saw' adds to the noisy, aggressive atmosphere. Frost repeats the phrase a few lines later: 'snarled and rattled, snarled and rattled'. The repetition and the steady rhythm imitate the relentless noise of the machine, and they create a sense of threat that hangs over the peaceful scene.
At first, though, the saw seems useful and harmless. It 'dropped stove-length sticks of wood', ready for the family's fires, and the wood is 'Sweet-scented stuff'. The soft sibilance contrasts with the harsh 'snarled', showing that the saw is part of ordinary farm work. Sometimes it 'had to bear a load', which almost makes it sound like a working animal or a labourer. This ordinariness makes the later violence more shocking.
The turning point comes when the sister calls 'Supper'. 'At the word', as if to show that 'saws knew what supper meant', the saw 'Leaped out at the boy's hand'. The personification reaches its climax: the saw seems to understand language, to be hungry and to spring at its prey. Frost places the clause about supper between the subject and the verb, delaying 'Leaped' and building suspense before the attack. The grim joke about 'what supper meant' suggests that the boy's hand becomes the saw's meal.
However, Frost does not let us simply blame the machine. He immediately adds 'or seemed to leap', and then 'He must have given the hand'. The narrator corrects himself, suggesting the boy may have slipped or been careless through tiredness. The phrase 'Neither refused the meeting' describes the boy and the saw as if they had an appointment, which makes the accident seem fated. This ambiguity is unsettling: the saw is both an innocent tool and a monster, depending on how we see it.
After the accident the saw is not mentioned again. The focus shifts entirely to the boy, the doctor and the watchers. This silence is effective: the noise that dominated the opening disappears, and the poem ends with the quiet of death and the adults turning 'to their affairs'. It is as if the saw has done its work and the farm will simply carry on.
Through the saw, Frost presents the dangers of the machines that children worked with on farms, but also something larger: a sense that the world is indifferent, and that ordinary objects can destroy a life in a moment. The personified saw becomes a symbol of fate, as sudden and merciless as the snuffing out of the candle in the title's allusion to Macbeth.
Explanation
The best answers analyse the personification closely ('snarled', 'Leaped', the saw that knew 'what supper meant') and explore its ambiguity: Frost presents the saw as a predator but also suggests the boy 'must have given the hand'. They comment on structure, such as the saw opening the poem and vanishing after the accident. Weaker answers identify personification without explaining its effect or its link to the poem's ideas about fate and work.
Mark scheme
-
12 marks
Levels of response (12 marks). AO1 (understanding and interpretation).
Select and interpret information, ideas and perspectives about the buzz saw.
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Basic selection of information and ideas; limited use of quotations or textual references; limited understanding, likely shown through retelling or paraphrase.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some selection of valid information and ideas; some use of valid quotations or references; some valid interpretation showing a developing understanding.
Level 3 (7-9 marks): Clear and relevant selection of information, ideas and perspectives; clear and relevant use of supporting quotations and references; relevant interpretation showing a clear understanding.
Level 4 (10-12 marks): Detailed and persuasive selection of information, ideas and perspectives; discriminating use of supporting quotations and references; perceptive interpretation showing a convincing understanding.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): The saw dominates the opening and is the first thing described; it is noisy and aggressive ('snarled and rattled'); it is also useful, cutting 'stove-length sticks of wood' for the household; it works steadily, whether it 'ran light' or had to 'bear a load'; at the call of 'Supper' it seems to leap at the boy's hand as if it understood the word; the narrator is unsure whether the saw leapt or the boy 'must have given the hand'; after the accident the saw is not mentioned again. Perceptive responses see the saw as both an ordinary tool and a predatory, almost living creature; as a symbol of fate or of the dangers of the adult working world; and note that the ambiguity of blame makes the accident more unsettling. Marking notes: mark AO1 and AO2 separately, each by best fit. A response that mainly retells the poem stays in Level 1 or 2. Misreadings of the poem limit the level. Context is credited only where it supports interpretation of the poem.
-
18 marks
Levels of response (18 marks). AO2 (analysis of language and structure).
Analyse how the poet uses language and structure to present the buzz saw.
Level 1 (1-3 marks): Limited identification of language and/or structural devices; limited selection of textual references; basic, simple comment on effects.
Level 2 (4-6 marks): Some identification of language and/or structural devices; some accurate textual references; some developing comment on effects.
Level 3 (7-10 marks): Clear and relevant selection of language and structural devices; relevant and generally appropriate textual references; clear explanation of effects.
Level 4 (11-14 marks): Thorough and confident selection of language and structural devices; confident and detailed textual references; detailed exploration of effects.
Level 5 (15-18 marks): Subtle and discriminating selection of language and structural devices; discriminating and assured use of textual references; perceptive analysis of effects.
0 marks: no rewardable material.Indicative content (not a checklist; credit other valid points): Personification: animal verbs 'snarled', 'Leaped'; 'rattled' suggests harshness and perhaps a snake's warning; onomatopoeia in 'buzz saw'; repetition of 'snarled and rattled, snarled and rattled' imitating relentless noise; contrast between the harsh consonants of the saw and the soft sibilance of 'Sweet-scented stuff'; the saw described almost as a labourer ('had to bear a load'); dark humour in the saw knowing 'what supper meant', as if the hand were its meal; delayed verb before 'Leaped' builds suspense; self-correction 'or seemed to leap'; 'Neither refused the meeting' presents saw and boy as equal partners in a fated encounter; the saw's silence after the accident; opening the poem with the saw makes it the subject of the first sentence. Marking notes: naming a device without explaining its effect gains little credit. From Level 3 upwards a response should comment on both language and structure. Quotations should be brief and precise; long copied passages are not discriminating.